Maternal satisfaction on quality of childhood vaccination services and its associated factors at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia

Abstract

Background

Vaccination is one of the most important public health interventions to reduce child mortality and morbidity. In Ethiopia, about 472,000 children die each year by vaccine-preventable diseases. A satisfied mother is assumed to use the services and complies with the service provider for better health care outcomes. However, there was no adequate evidence regarding maternal satisfaction with quality of childhood vaccination services. This study aimed to assess maternal satisfaction on quality of childhood vaccination services and its associated factors at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

Methods

A facility-based cross-sectional study was conducted from 12 July to 12 August 2021 at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. A total of 366 mothers (caretakers) of under one-year-old children participated in the study. A systematic sampling technique with an interviewer-administered questionnaire and inventory checklist were used to collect the data. A binary logistic regression model was fitted. Adjusted Odds Ratio (AOR) with 95% confidence interval (CI) and p-value < 0.05 were used to identify the factors associated with the outcome.

Results

Nearly two-thirds (61.2%) of mothers (caretakers) were satisfied with the quality of childhood vaccination services. Service providers’ greeting [AOR = 1.60; 95%CI: 1.37–1.99] and information about the types of vaccines [AOR = 1.54; 95%CI: 1.32–1.89] were positively associated with maternal satisfaction. On the contrary, long waiting time of mothers (caretakers) to receive services [AOR = 0.29; 95%CI: 0.14–0.62] was negatively associated with services.

Conclusion

The overall maternal satisfaction towards the quality of childhood vaccination services in this study was found to be low. Minimizing waiting time at the health facility, enhancing greetings and providing adequate information regarding childhood vaccination for mothers (caretakers) improved their satisfaction with the services.

Background

In 2015, about six million children died globally before the age of five, and over 3 million are died from vaccine-preventable infectious diseases [1]. In Ethiopia, about 472,000 children still die each year from vaccine-preventable diseases [2]. Majorities of childhood deaths are due to diseases that could be easily prevented with simple and affordable interventions such as vaccines [3]. Children are more susceptible to certain pathogens including vaccine-preventable infectious diseases due to their weak immunity [4]. As a result, vaccination is one of the most powerful health interventions that prevent 2–3 million deaths every year from vaccine-preventable diseases [2].

Vaccination is the process by which an individual’s immune system becomes fortified against an infectious disease by introducing a vaccine into the body that triggers an immune response [5]. Vaccines contain only killed or weakened forms of microorganisms like viruses or bacteria that do not cause the disease [6]. Vaccination is a key component of primary health care and a proven tool in preventing and eradicating infectious diseases [7]. It is a simple, safe and effective way of preventing and controlling infectious disease outbreaks [8, 9]. As a result, childhood immunization is considered a priority child health service in health facilities[10]. However, about 60% of children did not receive quality childhood vaccination services, particularly in sub-Saharan African countries [11].

The quality of childhood vaccination service depends on three domains: Structure, process, and outcome [12]. The driving forces towards the quality of childhood vaccination services include a clear understanding of the benefits of vaccination among community members, a readiness for providing vaccination by the health workers, and interventions to overcome barriers to vaccination services [13]. The quality of childhood vaccination services is also linked to the unavailability of vaccines, poor cold chain management, long waiting times, fear of side effects, long-distance travel, and being busy [14]. Maternal (caretaker) satisfaction is considered one of the most frequently used proxy indicators to measure the quality and efficiency of childhood vaccination services [11]. Accordingly, poor quality of childhood vaccination services is a major cause of morbidity and mortality of children due to vaccine-preventable diseases in developing countries[15] This can also cause a reduction in productivity, educational achievements, and economic growth [16]. A low level of maternal satisfaction with the quality of vaccination services may also enhance the self-medication of children using antibiotics associated with childhood illness among non-vaccinated children [12]. Even though there are studies in Ethiopia that evaluated the coverage of childhood immunization services [17, 18], there were no adequate evidences regarding maternal satisfaction on the quality of childhood vaccination services. Therefore, this study aimed to assess maternal satisfaction with the quality of childhood vaccination services and its associated factors at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

Methods and materials

Study design, setting, and population

A facility-based cross-sectional study was conducted from 12 July to 12 August 2021 at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Addis Ababa is the capital city of Ethiopia and is the largest city in the country. According to the city administrative health department biannual profile report, the city has 11 sub-cities, 12 public hospitals and 109 public health centers, and a total population of 4,567,857. The total number of eligible populations in the city who attended the expanded program of immunization (EPI) clinic in public health centers was about 13,500 per month.

Population

All mothers (caretakers) of under one year of children who attended childhood vaccination services at health centers in Addis Ababa city administration were the source population while those mothers (caretakers) who attended vaccination services for their children in the selected health centers were the study population. All mothers (caretakers) of under one year of children who were receiving immunization services at least one schedule within the selected sub-cities of Addis Ababa were included in the study. Mothers (caretakers) of under one year of children who were, severely ill and unable to respond were excluded from the study.

Sample size and sampling procedures

The sample size was determined using a single population proportion formula. It was computed by considering that a previous study has demonstrated the proportion of maternal satisfaction towards the quality of childhood vaccination service (68.2%) [19], a 95% confidence interval, 5% margin of error, and 10% non-response which yields the final sample size 366.

Four sub-cities and 33 health centers from these sub-cities were selected using simple random sampling. Then, the proportional allocation was done to each selected health center based on the previous one-month vaccination performances. Finally, a systematic sampling technique was employed and study participants were selected in every 3^rd interval.

Variables and measurements

The dependent variable was maternal satisfaction on the quality of childhood vaccination service while sociodemographic status, infrastructures, process, and access factors were the independent variables. Maternal satisfaction with the quality of childhood vaccination service was measured in eight items, each containing a five-point Likert scale (1 = very dissatisfied to 5 = very satisfied) alternatives. Therefore the total score could be ranged from 8–40 and then we used the demarcation threshold formula: $((\frac{\mathrm{Total}\;\mathrm{highest}\;\mathrm{score}\;-\;\mathrm{Total}\;\mathrm{lowest}\;\mathrm{score}}2)\;+\;\mathrm{Total}\;\mathrm{lowest}\;\mathrm{score})$ [20] to categorize the level of mothers(caretakers) satisfaction as “satisfied and dissatisfied”. Accordingly, mothers (caretakers) who scored above 60% on the satisfaction measurement tools were considered as satisfied otherwise not dissatisfied.

Data collection tools and procedures

A pre-tested interviewer-administered structured questionnaire was used to collect data. The data collection tool was adapted by reviewing a variety of literature [1, 21]. Furthermore, the Ethiopian Ministry of Health (MoH) inventory checklist was used to collect data related to the structure factors and process factors. The data collection tool was first prepared in English, translated to Amharic (the local language) then retranslated to English to check for consistency. Data collection was facilitated by four trained BSC nurses and two BSC midwifery nurse supervisors.

Data quality assurance and control

A day of training was given for both data collectors and supervisors on the data collection methods and procedures. The data collectors were followed by supervisors daily. To enhance instrument reliability, the instrument was pre-tested on 5% of sampled mothers (caretakers) of under one year children outside of the study area nearby healthcare facilities with similar characteristics to those in the study. The data was collected after a brief explanation of the aim of the study to the participants. The validity and completeness of the collected data were verified by the principal investigator and supervisors daily.

Data processing and analysis

Data were cleaned and entered into Epi info version 7.2.2.2 and exported to SPSS version 23 statistical software for analysis. A binary logistic regression was fitted to determine the association between dependent and independent variables. Variables with a p-value of less than 0.2 during bivariable regression were entered into multivariable logistic regression. Adjusted Odd Ratio (AOR) with a 95% confidence interval and p-value < 0.05 were used to declare the significant factors and strength of association. The model fitness was checked using the Hosmer Lemeshow goodness of fit test (88.6%) indicating that the model fitness was good. Descriptive statistics such as frequency, percentages, mean, and standard deviation (SD) were presented in the form of texts and tables.

Results

Socio-demographic characteristics

A total of 366 mothers (caretakers) of under one year children participated with a response rate of 100%. The mean age of mothers/caretakers was (25.6 ± 6.7 SD) years. More than one-third (41.5%) of the participants were housewives and 85.4% were married (Table 1).

Table 1 Socio-demographic characteristics of mothers (caretakers) attending EPI service at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2021 (n = 366)

Availability of infrastructures

All health centers had separate immunization rooms and 97.0% of them had a separate waiting area with chairs. Most health centers (97.0%) had adequate immunization registration books and tally sheets. Less than three-fourths (72.7%) of the health centers had pipe water. All health centers had at least one refrigerator whereas, 21.2% of health centers did not have a separate room for refrigerators and cold boxes (Table 2).

Table 2 Availability of organizational infrastructures for mothers receiving immunization service at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2021 (n = 33)

Access to vaccination services

The majority (80.9%) of mothers (caretakers) judged that the service was located at a convenient distance from their home. Moreover, 39.1% of mothers waited more than 45 min to receive the services (Table 3).

Table 3 Access to vaccination services for mothers receiving immunization services at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2021 (n = 366)

Process-related factors to vaccination services

Three-fourths (76.0%) of mothers (caretakers) had gotten vaccination services as per their previous appointments. About two-thirds (69.9%) of mothers (caretakers) were informed about the use and side effects of the administrated antigens but only 35% of them were informed about the types of vaccines given to their child. About 36.9% of mothers (caretakers) had gotten a proper greeting from the health care providers during their child vaccination session (Table 4).

Table 4 Process-related factors for mothers receiving immunization services at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2021 (n = 366)

Maternal satisfaction and its associated factors

Nearly two-thirds (61.2%) of mothers (caretakers) were satisfied with the overall quality of childhood vaccination services. Two-thirds (65.3%) and 61.2% of mothers/caretakers were satisfied with the cleanliness and availability of services, respectively. On the other hand, over half (52.0%) of mothers/caretakers were dissatisfied with access to drinking water, latrine, and hand-washing facilities (Table 5).

Table 5 Maternal satisfaction on the quality of childhood vaccination services at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2021 (n = 366)

Factors associated with maternal satisfaction

In the final multivariable logistic regression analysis, waiting time at the vaccination unit service provider greetings, and information about the types of vaccines were factors associated with mothers' (caretakers) satisfaction with the quality of vaccination services. The odds of client satisfaction with the quality of services among mothers (caretakers) waiting 30–45 min to receive services is significantly lower as compared to those who waited below 15 min [AOR = 0.38; 95%CI: 0.19–0.78]. Moreover, the odds of client satisfaction with the quality of services among mothers (caretakers) who had got greeting from providers was 1.60 times higher [AOR = 1.60; 95%CI: 1.37–1.99] as compared with their counterparts. Mothers (caretakers) who had got information about the types of vaccines were satisfied 1.54 times [AOR = 1.54; 95%CI: 1.32–1.89] compared with those who did not get information about the types of vaccines (Table 6).

Table 6 Factors associated with maternal satisfaction towards the quality of childhood vaccination services at public health centers in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 2021(n = 366)

Discussion

The overall maternal satisfaction towards the quality of childhood vaccination services in this study was found to be low. We also found that the major constraints that determine the satisfaction of mothers (caretakers) towards vaccination services were waiting time at the vaccination unit, service provider greetings, and information about the types of vaccines were factors associated with mothers' (caretakers’) satisfaction towards the quality of vaccination services.

Moreover, the finding of this study was relatively similar to the finding from Ondo State in Nigeria and North Wollo, Ethiopia which reported that the overall maternal satisfaction towards the quality of childhood vaccination services was (68.2%) and (68.9%) respectively [22, 19]. This consistency might be due to the similarity of the vaccination services delivery system.

Furthermore, the finding of this study was relatively higher as compared with the finding reported from Egypt (63%) [23], Calabar, south Nigeria (43.6%) [24], and Jigjiga, Ethiopia (30.1%) [25], However, the finding of this study was lower when compared with findings from New Cairo district, Egypt (74.4%) [26], Suez governorate, Egypt (95.2%) [27], Sokoto metropolis, Nigeria (75%) [28], Kombolicha, Ethiopia (71.9%) [21] and Hawasa city, Ethiopia (76.7%) [20]. This variation might be due to the existence of differences in cultural context towards vaccination services, and service delivery systems. Moreover, differences in the provision of refreshment training on vaccination services and healthcare providers' tendency towards using vaccination services guidelines and protocols might be attributed to the observed differences.

In this study, a long waiting time to find the services was found to be negatively influenced mothers' (caretakers) satisfaction. Mothers (caretakers) who had a waiting time of 30–45 min for service at the vaccination unit were less likely to be satisfied with the quality of childhood vaccination services compared with their counterparts. This finding was similar to the finding in Wadla district, Ethiopia [19], Kombolicha, Ethiopia [21], Jigjiga, Ethiopia [25], and India [14]. The possible justification might be because serving with short waiting time might be linked with accessing the services early and this could also increase the satisfaction of mothers (caretakers) towards the quality of childhood vaccination services.

Moreover, a friendly relationship between health care providers and mothers (caretakers) positively influenced mothers’ (caretakers’) satisfaction. Mothers (caretakers) who got greetings from providers were more likely to be satisfied with the quality of childhood vaccination services compared with mothers (caretakers) who did not get greetings. This finding was supported by the findings in Wadla district, Ethiopia [19], and Kombolicha, Ethiopia [21]. The possible justification might be due to effective interaction between service providers and service caretakers can contribute to the motivation of mothers' acceptance towards the vaccine services and it also increases the satisfaction of mothers with childhood vaccination services.

Information about the types of vaccines was also a significant predictor of maternal satisfaction with the quality of childhood vaccination services. Mothers (caretakers) who got information about the types of vaccines were 1.54 times more likely to be satisfied with the quality of childhood vaccination services than those who did not have information. The finding of this study was similar to a study conducted in Wadla district, Ethiopia [19], Jigjiga, Ethiopia [25] and Kombolcha city, Ethiopia [21]. This might be because having proper information about the types of vaccines enhances mothers' awareness so that they may have acceptance towards the services.

Limitations of the study

The limitation of this study is that it lacked qualitative aspects in assessing maternal satisfaction with the quality of childhood vaccination services and its associated factors. The other possible limitation of the study was that there might be a social desirability bias.

Conclusion

The maternal satisfaction with the quality of childhood vaccination services in this study was low. Long waiting time to find the services was found to be negatively influenced mothers' (caretakers) satisfaction. Moreover, a friendly relationship between health care providers and mothers (caretakers) positively influenced mothers' (caretakers') satisfaction. Precise and adequate information about the types of vaccines was also a positive predictor of maternal satisfaction with the quality of services.

Therefore, health sectors at each level and non-governmental organizations should work to improve the accessibility of services to caretakers. Healthcare providers should provide adequate information to mothers (caretakers) about vaccines and should have friendly interactions with mothers (caretakers). Moreover, healthcare providers had better adhere to vaccination services protocol. We also recommended future researchers to evaluate the quality of the services using a qualitative approach to get more general information.