From: The effectiveness of case management for cancer patients: an umbrella review
Outcomes | Measurements (No. of primary studies used the measurement) | |
---|---|---|
Global Quality of Life | FACT-G (n = 8) FACT-E (n = 1) FACT-B (n = 5) FACT-L (n = 1) EORTC QLQ-C30 (n = 11) SF-36 (n = 5) SF-12(n = 4) SF-8 (n = 1) EORTC-11 (n = 2) Spitzer Quality of Life Index (n = 2) SDS (n = 2) PHQ (n = 1) ESDS (n = 1) HADS (n = 1) MUIS (n = 1) Karnofsky Performance Status (n = 1) Visual analogue scale (n = 1) | |
Functional status (i.e. Physical, Cognitive, emotional, role, social) | Psychological function | HADS (n = 8) CES-D: depression (n = 4) Impact of Event Scale (n = 2) SF-36 (n = 1) CARES-SF (n = 1) Brief Symptom Inventory: anxiety (n = 1) Depressive symptom subscale of the POMS (n = 1) Hamilton rating scale for anxiety (n = 1) Affects Balance Scale (n = 1) Cancer Rehabilitation Evaluation (n = 1) 28-item general health questionnaire (n = 1) |
Physical function | SF-36 (n = 2) Objective assessment of arm functions (n = 1) IPAQ leisure-time activity subscale and records (n = 1) | |
Role function | Sick leave days (n = 4) Rate/numbers of return to work(n = 4) Social adjustment (n = 1) Employment patterns (n = 1) IPAQ leisure-time activity subscale (n = 1) | |
Cognitive function | MUIS (n = 5) IPAQ leisure-time activity subscale (n = 1) | |
Emotional function | POMS (n = 4) SF-36 five-item mood state score & role-emotional and mental health subscales (n = 2) EORTC C-30 (n = 1) | |
Social function | SF-36 (n = 1) Social Support Questionnaire (n = 1) The Dyadic Satisfaction and Dyadic Cohesion subscales from the 32-item Spanier Dyadic Adjustment Scale (n = 1) | |
Symptom management | Symptom overall | SF-36 (n = 4) SDS (n = 4) Profile of Mood States questionnaire (n = 2) SCL-20 (n = 1) SCL-90 (n = 1) ESDS (n = 1) PHQ (n = 1) Standard questions on symptom severity (n = 1) Inventory of Current Concerns (n = 1) Physiologic complication classification (n = 1) Memorial Symptom Assessment Scale (n = 1) Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (n = 1) CES-D (n = 1) Chemotherapy Symptom Assessment Scale (n = 1) Distress thermometer (n = 1) |
Pain | McGill pain questionnaire (n = 2) Visual analogue scale (n = 2) Intensity subscale of the Brief Pain Inventory (n = 1) | |
Fatigue | FACIT-F (n = 2) Brief Fatigue Inventory (n = 2) General Fatigue Scale (n = 1) Fatigue symptom subscale (n = 1) | |
Sleep | Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index /Inventory: Sleep (n = 1) | |
Self-efficacy | General Self-Efficacy Scale (n = 1) Cancer Behavior Inventory (n = 1) Strategies Used by Patients to Promote Health (n = 1) Self-developed questionnaire (n = 1) | |
Survivor status (e.g., Length of survival) | Medical records (n = 5) | |
Patient satisfaction | Self-developed patient satisfaction questionnaire (n = 7) Patient satisfaction (n = 1) Medical Outcomes Study-Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire (n = 1) Satisfaction and Accessibility scales (n = 1) | |
Cost | Billing systems (n = 4) Health care costs (n = 3) Medical records (n = 3) Time logs (n = 1) Euro Qol 5D (n = 1) | |
Hospital (re)admissions | Patients’ number of hospital admissions (n = 4) ICU admission rate (n = 1) | |
Length of Stay /hospitalizations | length of stay in hospital/ ICU (n = 2) Medical records audit (n = 2) Hospitalization: Any episode of client hospitalization which respired an overnight stay (n = 1) Referral rate: Number of cancer patients referred to home care per 100,000 population (n = 1) | |
Treatment received compliance (e.g., intention, acceptance, completion) | Therapy acceptance rate (n = 6) Therapy completion rate (n = 3) Medical records audit (n = 1) Rate of patient continuing treatment (n = 1) Patient Assessment of Chronic Illness Care (n = 1) | |
Provision of timely treatment | Time from diagnosis to treatment (n = 3) |