Trends of increase in western medical services in traditional medicine hospitals in china
BMC Health Services Research volume 11, Article number: 212 (2011)
Compare changes in types of hospital service revenues between traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) hospitals and Western-medicine based general hospitals.
97 TCM hospitals and 103 general hospitals were surveyed in years of 2000 and 2004. Six types of medical service revenue between the two types of hospitals were compared overtime. The national statistics from 1999 to 2008 were also used as complementary evidence.
For TCM hospitals, the percentage of service revenue from Western medicine increased from 44.3% to 47.4% while the percentage of service revenue from TCM declined from 26.4% to 18.8% from 1999 to 2004. Percentages of revenue from laboratory tests and surgical procedures for both types of hospitals increased and the discrepancy between the two types of hospitals was narrowed from 1999 to 2004. For TCM hospitals, revenues from laboratory tests increased from 3.64% to 5.06% and revenues from surgical procedures increased from 3.44% to 7.02%. General hospitals' TCM drug revenue in outpatient care declined insignificantly from 5.26% to 3.87%, while the decline for the TCM hospitals was significant from 19.73% to 13.77%. The national statistics from 1999 to 2008 showed similar trends that the percentage of revenue from Western medicine for TCM hospitals increased from 59.6% in 1999 to 62.2% in 2003 and 66.1% in 2008 while the percentage of revenue from TCM for TCM hospitals decreased from 18.0% in 1999, 15.4% in 2003, and 13.7% in 2008.
Western medicine has become a vital revenue source for TCM hospitals in the current Chinese health care environment where government subsidies to health care facilities have significantly declined. Policies need to encourage TCM hospitals to identify their own special and effective services, improve public perception, increase demand, strengthen financial sources, and ultimately make contributions to preserving one of the national treasures.
As the primary form of healthcare service in many developing countries, complementary and alternative medicine has become more popular in the world including in a number of developed countries in recent years . Given the changes in disease patterns in recent decades where chronic and functional diseases, such as malignant tumor, high blood pressure, cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disease and diabetes, have become leading diseases/conditions, people began to look for solutions from alternative medical care, which has led to the rapid development and dissemination of traditional medicine [2, 3]. The World Health Organization reports that 65 - 80% of the world population uses traditional medicine as their main type of healthcare service . There were US$ 60 billion sales in the global herbal medicines market in 2000 , and by 2003, 54 countries had legalized traditional medicine (including traditional Chinese medicine) .
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) has over 2,000 years of history in China and is well known as the quintessence of Chinese culture . It has made indelible contributions to the well- being of the Chinese people [8, 9]. As one type of CAM, TCM has also become an important part of health care in East Asia countries/regions, such as China, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, and Malaysia. Some TCM services such as acupuncture have been utilized in some developed countries such as Japan, Great Britain, Canada, and the United States, where it has been legalized .
Since 1949, the development of TCM has consistently been a health policy priority in China. In the 1950s, "Integrating TCM and Western medicine" was one of the three guidelines for health care development . The government believed that the provision of adequate health services to billions of people would be impossible unless TCM was included in health care delivery . In the 1980s, the central government emphasized that delivering health services through both TCM and Western medicine, as well as their integration, should be a long-term national policy. Moreover, the central government also set up quantitative indictors for characterizing TCM hospitals. County-level TCM hospitals are required to have at least 85% and 70% of their prescriptions based on either raw herbal medicines or processed herbal medicine for outpatient and inpatient services, respectively . The county-level TCM hospitals are also required to have a minimum of 70% health professionals whose primary training is in TCM .
In the 1990s, the government issued one of the most important health care reform policies that stressed that high quality health services should be based on the integration of TCM and Western medicine . TCM has experienced unprecedented rapid growth, from only four TCM hospitals nationwide with an average of 30 beds per hospital in 1950 to 2,688 TCM hospitals with a total of 350 thousand beds in 2008 . For health care providers, TCM has also become an important part of their integrated medical practice .
However, even with a continuous policy emphasis, TCM services seem to be strongly affected by the growth of Western medicine in recent years [18, 19]. Furthermore, there has been virtually no published research on the extent of the westernization of TCM services based on our literature search. This study, therefore, compares types of revenue between TCM hospitals and the Western-medicine based general hospitals in China overtime and examines what these financial trends indicate concerning the Westernization of TCM hospitals. Findings of this study serve as an evaluation of the overall effectiveness of the national policy during the last 30 years to support the growth of TCM in China, and they can be used to help develop strategies to sustain and strengthen TCM .
Study design and sampling. To examine whether TCM hospitals have become more westernized over time, we hypothesized that the traditional Chinese hospitals have become more dependent on Western medical services such as laboratory tests, surgeries, as well as Western medicine. Data were obtained from two hospital surveys conducted in 1999 and 2004, respectively. We used both cross sectional and panel models to conduct the data analysis. In addition, we used the similar national statistics from 1999 to 2008 to verify consistency between our findings and the national trends.
We used the stratified randomization sampling method in 1999 for the first survey. First, we categorized the 31 Chinese provinces as Eastern, Middle, and Western regions, which generally represent well-developed, moderately-developed, and under-developed regions of China. Two provinces are drawn from each region. They are Zhejiang and Jiangsu, Jiangxi and Hunan, and Sichuan and Shaanxi in the Eastern, Middle, and Western regions, respectively. Second, in each of the six provinces, we further categorized cities into three groups based on their levels of economic development. Three cities were drawn from each level. Third, we used the same method to randomly choose three counties from all counties that are administratively affiliated with a city. Finally, we included general and TCM hospitals from each county. Hence, for each province, we collected data in three cities and nine counties. The survey stopped if there was no general hospital or TCM hospital in a selected county. As result, the final sample contained a total of 200 hospitals, 97 TCM hospitals and 103 general hospitals, and six cities/counties had more than one general hospitals. The same hospitals were followed-up in 2004 for the second survey.
Measures. During the two survey periods, data for bed size and various types of revenues were abstracted. Six response variables were identified to measure types of revenue from the different services. They were: 1) the percentage of total service revenue from laboratory tests, 2) the percentage of total service revenue from surgeries, 3) percentage of total service revenue from TCM prescriptions in outpatient services, 4) percentage of total service revenues from TCM prescriptions in inpatient services, 5) percentage of total service revenue from the Western medicine prescriptions in outpatient services, and 6) percentage of total service revenue from the Western medicine prescriptions in inpatient services. The two main independent variables were hospital type (a value of "1" for TCM versus a value of"0" for general hospital) and year (a value of "1" for the year of 2004 versus a value of "0" for the year of 1999).
Data analysis. We applied both a pooled cross sectional fixed effect model and a panel design, random effect model in investigating the relationship between hospital type and the six dependent variables over time, respectively. The panel design fixed model was not utilized, because there was no change in hospital type over time . The cross sectional fixed model was able to take into account unmeasured between-hospital variation, while the panel random effect method took into account the dependence of the repeated measures of the hospitals during the two surveys. By conducting the multivariable analysis using two different but complementary methods, we were able to check the consistency of our findings.
Several hospital characteristics were controlled for in the multivariable analysis that was conducted using the STATA Version 11 software. The hospital characteristics included the number of staffed beds (in 100 s), level of hospital (i.e., city or county hospital), and region where the hospital was located. As a common practice, China categorizes its hospitals by three levels. The province-level hospital is the largest in size and most advanced, the county-level hospital is the smallest in size and least advanced, and the city-level hospital is in-between. All of the survey hospitals were public ones.
Unadjusted descriptive statistics of characteristics TCM hospitals and other hospitals are shown in Table 1. The top panel of Table 1 displays the results of the 200 hospitals we surveyed. From 1999 to 2004, both TCM hospitals and general hospitals grew in bed size and total revenues. The average bed sizes were 173 beds for the TCM hospitals and 413 beds for the general hospitals in 1999, whereas the numbers of beds were 210 and 467 for the TCM and general hospitals, respectively, in 2004. The general hospitals were sizably larger than TCM hospitals in terms of the number of staffed beds and total revenues. In 2004, the average bed size of traditional Chinese hospitals was only 45% that of general hospitals and the total revenue was only 36%. The percentages of government subsidies as a percentage of total revenue dropped from 7.2% to 4.7% for the TCM hospitals and from 4.8% to 3.4% for the general hospitals between 1999 and 2004.
The bottom panel of Table 1 shows the national statistics of TCM hospitals and other hospitals from 1999 to 2008. Both TCM hospitals and other types of hospitals had grown in bed size and other hospitals were sizably larger than TCM hospitals. The percentage of government subsidies slightly increased for both TCM hospitals (9.5%, 9.3%, and 10.6% for 1999, 2003, and 2008, respectively) and other hospitals (7.7%, 8.3%, and 8.5% for 1999, 2003, and 2008, respectively).
Table 2 shows the revenue sources of TCM hospitals and other hospitals. The top panel of Table lists the results of the 200 hospitals. More than half of the service revenues came from outpatient services for the TCM hospitals, while outpatient service revenues were less than half for the general hospitals. The percentage of revenue from Western medicine for the TCM hospitals increased (44.3% and 47.4% for 1999 and 2004, respectively) and the percentage of revenue from TCM for the TCM hospitals decreased (26.4% and 18.8% for 1999 and 2004, respectively). Similarly, the percentages of revenues generated from laboratory tests and surgeries increased for both types of hospitals over time. Laboratory revenue as a percent of total service revenue for the TCM hospitals increased from 4.1% in 1999 to 5.7% in 2004 while surgical revenue as a percent of total service revenue increased from 3.4% in 1999 to 6.9% in 2004. It is surprising that the TCM hospitals had a higher percentage of revenues from Western medicine prescriptions in outpatient care (20.1% in 1999 and 15.6% in 2004) than their general hospital counterparts (17.3% in 1999 and 14.5% in 2004). The percentage of TCM drug revenue as a percentage of total drug revenue dropped from 41.2% to 34.2% for the TCM hospitals and from 14.4% to 10.4% for the general hospitals between 1999 to 2004, and more decline was observed in outpatient care versus inpatient care.
The national statistics from 1999 to 2008 show similar trends (the bottom panel of Table 2). The percentage of revenue from Western medicine for TCM hospitals increased (59.6% in 1999, 62.2% in 2003, and 66.1% in 2008) and the percentage of revenue from TCM for TCM hospitals decreased (18.0% in 1999, 15.4% in 2003, and 13.7% in 2008). Specifically, laboratory revenue as a percent of total service revenue were 7.6%, 8.8%, and 10.4% in 1999, 2003, and 2008, respectively, and surgical revenues as a percent of total service revenue were 3.4%, 4.9%, and 5.7% in 1999, 2003, and 2008, respectively. Furthermore, TCM drug revenue as a percent of total drug revenue declined from 18.0% in 1999 to 15.4% in 2003, and 13.7% in 2008.
Results of the multivariable analysis of the cross sectional models are shown in Table 3. For the six dependent variables, compared with general hospitals, TCM hospitals had lower percentages of revenues for three types of revenue, a comparable percentage for one type, and higher percentages for two types. Specifically, their percentages of revenues from laboratory tests, surgical procedures, and inpatient Western drug prescriptions were 1.01%, 1.96%, and 8.94% lower than those of their general hospital counterparts, and their percentage of revenue for outpatient care Western medicine was comparable to their general hospital counterparts in 1999. Moreover, for the general hospitals, the percentages of revenue from laboratory tests and surgical procedures increased by 1.24% and 2.43% from 1999 to 2004, respectively, but the percentages of revenue from outpatient Western drug prescriptions decreased by 3.98% from 1999 to 2004. Since none of the interaction terms between TCM and time was statistically significant, the differences between the two types of hospitals did not change significantly over time, meaning that for the TCM hospitals, from 1999 to 2004, the percentages of revenue from laboratory tests and surgical procedures increased by 1.32% and 3.58%, respectively, and the percentages of revenue from outpatient Western drug prescriptions decreased by 3.98%.
Understandably, the two higher percentages of drug revenues for the TCM hospitals were from TCM prescription drugs in outpatient and inpatient care, respectively. While the discrepancy in inpatient care between the two types of hospitals remained unchanged over time, the discrepancy in outpatient care significantly narrowed. For the general hospitals, the TCM drug revenue as a percentage of total service revenues for outpatient care declined insignificantly from 5.26% to 3.87% from 1999 to 2004, while there was a significant decline for the TCM hospitals from 19.73% to 13.77% during the same period.
Results from the multivariable panel model, as shown in Table 4, were generally consistent to those findings in Table 3. There was one more statistically significant interaction in the percentage of revenue from surgical procedures, indicating that the discrepancies in the percentage of revenues from surgical procedures between the two types of hospitals narrowed by 1.24% from 1999 to 2004. Specifically, revenues for surgical procedures increased from 5.51% to 7.91% for the general hospitals between 1999 and 2004, but they more than doubled from 3.43% to 7.07%, for TCM hospitals during the same period.
Our findings indicate that the Western medicine is a vital and major financial source for the survival of TCM hospitals in China. Most TCM hospital's revenues are generated though providing services based on the Western medicine. Although we used revenue to approximate the number of prescriptions, it is obvious that TCM hospitals are far from meeting the national standard that they prescribe at least 85% and 70% of their prescriptions based on herbal medicines for the outpatient and inpatient services, respectively . More undesirably, TCM hospitals' percentage of TCM medication revenue, instead of moving up towards the national standard, has gone down over time. The gradual increase in Western medicine in the TCM hospitals is leading to the demise of their traditional features and strengths, which, in turn, is resulting in the weakening of their competitive advantages over general hospitals in local markets .
While differences in inpatient drug prescriptions between TCM hospitals and general hospitals remained steady over time, TCM hospitals have become more similar to general hospitals in regard to outpatient prescriptions. This is particularly significant given that TCM hospitals rely more financially on outpatient care than general hospitals, since more than half of their service revenues come from outpatient services. The gap in outpatient care has been narrowed, which demonstrates yet another isomorphic behavior between the two types of hospitals. It is not to understand why TCM hospitals do not prioritize traditional medications over Western medications. This "Westernization" behavior indicates TCM hospitals' pragmatic approach in order to survive.
Both TCM and general hospitals utilized more lab tests and surgeries, which are Western medicine practices, to boost their revenues in 2004 as compared to 1999. The national data from 1999 to 2008 observed the similar increase. Moreover, the increase in TCM hospitals' percentage of surgical revenues was larger than that of general hospitals over time. This further indicates that TCM hospitals have become more "Westernized" in terms of revenue sources.
There are several explanations for why TCM hospitals are becoming more like general hospitals. First of all, demand for TCM services has declined. It is reported that 94.8% of rural residents prefer to see a Western medicine doctor first when they are sick, as compared to only 5.2% of them who choose to see a TCM doctor first . Research has also suggested that 84.9% of health care providers and health care administrators prefer to seek out Western medical care first when they get sick, compared to 15.1% who would choose TCM first . It appears that TCM service providers may also relegate TCM services to the second place. It seems to be that, along with the fast economic growth, modern and advanced Western medicine has become more popular and acceptable and, at the same time, the public trust to and confidence about slowly updated TCM are facing challenges in China, which negatively affects its demand. Given the fact that government subsidies have significantly shrunk and that most of hospital revenues are generated from medical services delivery, lack of demand for services threatens the financial variability of TCM hospitals. They have to rely on more popular Western medicine as their primary revenue source in order to survive.
Second, the national policy of promoting TCM, especially the "Let each county have a TCM hospital" initiative, does not seem to have achieved its policy goals. In contrast, TCM hospitals appear to downplay TCM. The original intention to build TCM hospitals for all counties was to increase the access to and availability of TCM services. However, instead of offering TCM care as their primary services, TCM health care providers and hospitals are providing more and more Western medical services. Our findings show increases in the proportions of total revenues generated by Western medicine oriented lab tests and surgeries, as well as the proportion of the total medication revenue generated from Western drugs. Given that TCM hospitals are growing more similar to general hospitals, one may raise a question about whether it is necessary to have a stand-alone TCM hospital in each county, regardless of the demand for TCM in that county. Moreover, the TCM policy failed to build well-functioning TCM hospitals with typical and strong TCM features. The "Let each county have a TCM hospital" policy was supposed to speed up the development of TCM services, but newly built TCM hospitals are becoming more like general hospitals in the services they provide.
The TCM hospital's behavior of providing less and less TCM care may be also related to its own features and characteristics which cannot keep up with Western medicine in market competition. Compared to Western medicine, TCM treatment processes are often longer and non-replicable and their treatment outcomes are more delayed. In addition, TCM is not particularly effective in dealing with acute or/and infectious diseases . As a result, TCM hospitals face a dilemma in the current health care environment. Socially, it is a privilege and moral responsibility for TCM hospitals to maintain the national treasure by offering most of their services based on TCM. On the other hand, TCM hospitals must keep themselves financially healthy. To achieve that, they have no choice but to provide more Western medicine because revenues generated from TCM services are not sufficient. Studies have shown that TCM hospitals that tried to keep TCM as their primary revenue source experienced slow growth, decline of service volume, shrinking market share, and ultimately they were struggling for survival . It is reported that one-third of TCM hospitals struggle financially and are in danger of being shut down, merged, or relocated . It is understandable why TCM hospitals provide more and more Western medicine based care.
Several limitations existed in this research. First, we compared TCM and general hospitals in percentage of revenues for laboratory tests, surgeries, and prescription drugs. Other types of revenues, such as registration fees, physician service fees, and diagnostic fees, were not examined because the information could not be distinguished between TCM and Western health care providers within hospitals. In addition, given the focus on types of revenues in this study, we did not compare health care providers and other human resource factors between TCM and general hospitals. Third, due to the inconsistency between the 1999 and 2004 surveys, revenue generated from high-tech services, such as MRI, CT, and ultrasonic, were not investigated. Fourth, due to the limited sample size, hospitals at different levels or regions were not analyzed separately. Fifth, the non-randomization in selecting the hospitals might limit the generalibilty of our findings and the data we used are seven years old. Nevertheless, the more recent national statistics from 1999 to 2008 showed the same trends of Westernization of TCM hospitals we found in the study. Finally, most of the cited literature is in Chinese, which makes it difficult for English readers to trace the original articles.
Even with the strong national policy support to enhance TCM access and availability and TCM is an important part of integrated medical practice , TCM hospitals still tend to become more Westernized. It is important to understand why the implementation of the policies deviates from the original goals. The reality is that Western medicine is a vital revenue source for the survival of TCM hospitals, and they have become more reliant on it in the current health care environment in China where government subsidies to health care facilities have significantly declined. In order to maintain the vigorousness of traditional Chinese medicine, policies to strengthen TCM should re-emphasize their standards or requirements (e.g., for TCM hospitals, 80% TCM prescriptions for outpatient care and 70% for inpatient care) and they should allocate special funds for updating and upgrading TCM. More specifically, instead of the general support and across the board fund allocation policy that has been implemented for over three decades, policies need to support efforts of identifying a range of specific TCM services that are more effective than Western medicine in dealing with certain diseases, especially some chronic diseases and clinical conditions related to aging. Each TCM hospital needs to eventually develop its own TCM related clinical specialties. By doing so, TCM hospitals can gain comparative advantage over Western medicine hospitals, improve public perception, increase demand, strengthen financial sources, and ultimately go beyond just survival and make contributions to preserving one of the national treasures of China.
Yee S, Chu S, Xu Y, Choo PL: Regulatory control of Chinese proprietary medicines in Singapore. Health policy. 2005, 71: 139-44.
Eisenberg DM, Davis RB, Ettner SL, Appel S, Wilkey S, Van Rompay M, Kessler RC: Trends in alternative medicine use in the United States, 1990-1997. Journal of the American Medical Association. 1998, 280 (18): 1569-75. 10.1001/jama.280.18.1569.
Kaptchuk TJ: In the web that has no weaver: understanding Chinese medicine. 2000, New York (NY): McGraw-Hill, 2
Anonymous: Program profile: international liaison brings global vision to OAM. Complementary and alternative medicine at the NIH. 1996, 3: 3.
Zhang XR: Traditional medicine with health care and the impact of globalization on protection of traditional medicine. The Seventh International Conference on the Impact of Globalization on Development and Health Care Services in Islamic Countries, Kuwait. 2002
Zhang LB, Zhang DY, Fu YL: International trends of development of traditional Chinese medicine. The Journal of Beijing Traditional Chinese Medical University. 2007, 30 (3): 149-52.
Zheng R: A historical review of traditional Chinese medicine policies. The Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine Information. 2006, 13 (8): 103-4.
Huang CG, Chen SZ: Growth of traditional Chinese medicine in China - challenges and opportunities. The Chinese Journal of Ethnic and Folk Medicine. 2004, 67: 63-5.
Chan K: Progress in traditional Chinese medical care. Trends in Pharmacological Sciences. 1995, 6 (16): 182-7.
Chi C, Lee JW, Lai J: The practice of Chinese medicine in Taiwan. Social Science and Medicine. 1996, 9 (43): 1329-48.
Liang WN, Hao M: Healthcare services administration. 2003, Beijing: People's Health Press
Committee of the Contemporary China Series: The healthcare services of contemporary China (part 2). 1986, Beijing: China Social Science Press
Chen LJ: A ten-year review of the Traditional Chinese Medicine Model County Program. The Chinese Journal of Rural Health Administration. 1998, 18 (11): 21-2.
Chen LJ: The milestone of county level traditional Chinese medicine hospital development. Journal of Soft Science in Healthcare. 1999, 13 (3): 14.
The Central Committee of Chinese Communism Party and the State Council: Decision on healthcare reform and development. Office of Ministry of Health's Document Achieves on Healthcare Reform and Development. 1997, 7 (2).
Ministry of Health: The Chinese health statistics annual book. 2009, Beijing: China Union Medical College Press
Harmsworth K, Lewith GT: Attitudes to traditional Chinese medicine amongst Western trained doctors in the People's Republic of China. Social Science and Medicine. 2001, 52 (1): 149-53. 10.1016/S0277-9536(00)00124-6.
Jin GL: Reasons and strategies of the Westernization of traditional Chinese medicine. The Chinese Journal of Medicine and Pharmacy. 2000, 5 (6): 6-9.
Hao M, Zhu NS, Lin ZH, Shen J: Feasibility study of keeping the traditional Chinese medicine features among county level TCM hospitals. Journal of Chinese Hospital Management. 1991, 11 (10): 38-41.
The National Development and Reform Commission: 2008
Allison P: Fixed effects regression methods for longitudinal data using SAS. 2005, Carry, NC: SAS Press
Wen CL: Enhancing traditional Chinese medicine features in the TCM hospital reform. The Chinese Journal of Hospital Management. 1996, 1 (4): 241-3.
Wang Y, Xu P, Hao M: The crisis of traditional Chinese medicine development from perspectives of healthcare service organizers and providers. The Chinese Journal of Health Resources. 2005, 4 (8): 163-5.
Zhao L: Development and sustainability of traditional Chinese hospitals in new socioeconomic environments. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine Administration. 1998, 8 (6): 28-30.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6963/11/212/prepub
This study was, in part, funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grant number 70733002 and the Program for Changjiang Scholars and Innovative Research Team in University grant number IRT0912 from Ministry of Education of China.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
JS participated in design of study, data analysis and interpretation, statistical methods, manuscript draft, administrative and technical assistance, and supervision. YW participated in design and concept of study, acquisition of data, manuscript draft, and administrative and material assistance. FL participated in data analysis and interpretation and manuscript draft. JL participated in concept of the study and acquisition of data. CM participated in data analysis and interpretation and manuscript draft. MS participated in concept of study and acquisition of data. MH participated in design and concept of study, acquisition of data, manuscript draft, acquisition of funding, and supervision. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Jay J Shen, Ying Wang contributed equally to this work.
About this article
Cite this article
Shen, J.J., Wang, Y., Lin, F. et al. Trends of increase in western medical services in traditional medicine hospitals in china. BMC Health Serv Res 11, 212 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6963-11-212
- traditional Chinese medicine
- Western medicine
- health policy