Skip to main content

Table 4 Delphi survey on transfers between nursing homes and emergency care facilities in Norway

From: Areas of consensus on unwarranted and warranted transfers between nursing homes and emergency care facilities in Norway: a Delphi study

Delphi factor

First round

Second Round

 

Third Round

  
 

% of score ≥ 7

IQR

Consensus Level

% of score ≥ 7

IQR

Consensus Level

Stability

% of score ≥ 7

IQR

Consensus Level

Stability

P-value < 0.05

Transfer should not happen when:

 

It reduces residents expected lifetime significantly

94%

0

Very high

97%

0

Very high

Yes

100%

0

Very High

Yes

 

It reduces life quality in the long run

87%

1

High

95%

0

Very high

Yes

95%

1

High

Yes

 

Non-transfer preference in preliminary talk

98%

1

High

97%

1

High

Yes

98%

1

High

Yes

 

Significant delirium risk attached

75%

3

Moderate

86%

2

High

No

75%

2

Moderate

No

Gen (1,3) (-)

MD (3)(-)

Resident expresses transfer is not wanted

87%

1

High

94%

1

High

Yes

96%

1

High

Yes

 

Next-of-kin expresses transfer not wanted

73%

3

Low

77%

1

Low

No

63%

1

Low

No

 

Resident is in a palliative state

96%

0

Very high

97%

0

Very high

Yes

98%

0

Very High

Yes

 
  1. Table columns: round, consensus (% of score ≥ 7), inter-quartile range IQR, stability between the round and the previous one, and significant differences (P-value < 0.05) in answers by panel characteristics gender Gen, profession MD or rurality Urb
  2. Bold font: consensus
  3. Minus (-) indicates lower agreement, ( +) expresses higher agreement with the statement
  4. Gender (Gen) has male set as 1
  5. Urbanity (Urb) is a Statistics Norway measure of rurality
  6. The questions are ranked in the order they were presented in the project proposal pre-randomized Delphi-survey
  7. Logistic regression was used to determine significant differences in coefficients