Skip to main content

Table 3 Elements of support per time period (absolute numbers and rounded percentages)

From: Support for relatives in the intensive care unit: lessons from a cross-sectional multicentre cohort study during the COVID-19 pandemic

 

Pre-COVID-19 (n = 95)

First COVID-19 wave (n = 130)

Second COVID-19 wave (n = 104)

Total (n = 329)

p-value

WHO

 Received support from a support team

0b

94 (72.3)

0c

94 (28.6)

 < 0.001

 Support received from..g

  Attending ICU nurse

93 (97.9)

114 (87.7)

100 (96.2)

307 (93.3)

0.004

  Attending ICU physician

86 (90.5)

85 (65.4)

87 (83.7)

258 (78.4)

 < 0.001

  Non-ICU healthcare professional

N/A

71 (54.6)

9 (8.7)

80 (34.2)

 < 0.001

  Psychosocial caregiver

29 (30.5)

31 (23.8)

25 (24.0)

85 (25.8)

0.477

  Othera

1 (1.1)

0 (0)

0 (0)

1 (0.3)

0.289

WHEN

 Frequency of contact

    

0.050

  Less than 1 time per day

7 (7.4)

3 (2.3)

5 (4.8)

15 (4.6)

 

  1 time per day

32 (34.0)

55 (42.3)

33 (31.7)

120 (36.6)

 

   > 1 time per day

41 (43.6)

66 (50.8)

53 (51.0)

160 (48.8)

 

  Other

14 (14.9)

6 (4.6)

13 (12.5)

33 (10.1)

 

 Fixed timeslot for contact

5 (5.3)

80 (62.0)

19 (18.3)

104 (31.7)

 < 0.001

HOW

 Method of contactg

     

  Healthcare professional called relative

N/A

99 (78.6)

34 (32.7)

133 (57.5)d

 < 0.001

  Relative called healthcare professional

N/A

64 (50.8)

68 (65.4)

132 (57.4)d

0.032

  Othera

N/A

3 (2.4)

2 (1.9)

5 (2.2)d

1.000

WHAT

 Relative received information (e.g. leaflets) about..g

     

  Working method ICU

73 (80.2)

89 (70.1)

69 (67.0)

231 (72.0)

0.106

  Visitation policy

90 (96.8)

89 (73.6)

96 (92.3)

275 (86.5)

 < 0.001

  Isolation measures

N/A

79 (62.7)

82 (79.6)

161 (70.3)

0.006

  Patient’s disease

88 (95.7)

67 (52.3)

53 (52.0)

208 (64.6)

 < 0.001

  Available support

42 (47.7)

65 (51.2)

34 (33.3)

141 (44.3)

0.017

 Topics discussed in conversations with healthcare professionalsg

  General COVID-19 information

0b

26 (20.2)

17 (16.5)

43 (18.5)d

0.501

  General ICU information

26 (27.4)

31 (24.0)

26 (25.2)

83 (25.4)

0.863

  Changes in medical situation

94 (98.9)

125 (96.9)

101 (98.1)

320 (97.9)

0.642

  Physical examination and results

74 (77.9)

101 (78.3)

70 (68.0)

245 (74.9)

0.146

  Treatment

82 (86.3)

112 (86.8)

82 (79.6)

276 (84.4)

0.280

  Complications

52 (54.7)

93 (72.1)

51 (49.5)

196 (59.9)

0.001

  Stopping treatment

37 (38.9)

42 (32.6)

32 (31.1)

111 (33.9)

0.478

  PICS(-F)

10 (10.5)

11 (8.5)

5 (4.9)

26 (8.0)

0.332

  Worries about the patient

47 (49.5)

76 (58.9)

51 (49.5)

174 (53.2)

0.251

  Worries about own wellbeing and of relatives and how to inform them

11 (11.6)

52 (40.3)

15 (14.6)

78 (23.9)

 < 0.001

  Othera

0 (0)

5 (3.9)

1 (1.0)

6 (1.8)

0.113

 Video calling between patient and relative possible

30 (32.3)

110 (86.6)

71 (71.0)

211 (65.9)

 < 0.001

 Being offered emotional support

60 (63.2)

91 (74.0)

70 (68.8)

221 (69.1)

0.239

VISITIATION POLICY

 Visitors allowed

95 (100)b

15 (11.5)

103 (99.0)

213 (64.7)

 < 0.001

 Allowed to say goodbye in persona,e

25 (100)b

37 (94.9)

24 (96.0)

86 (96.6)

0.785

 Saying goodbye in a private roomf

17 (89.5)

19 (54.3)

17 (73.9)

53 (68.8)

0.024

  1. Missing values: frequency of contact 1, fixed timeslot 1, method of contact 4, working method ICU 8, visitation policy 11, isolation measures 5, patient’s disease 7, available support 11, all topics 2, video calling 9, emotional support 9, allowed to say goodbye 1, saying goodbye private room 1
  2. N/A Not asked
  3. aFisher’s exact test instead of chi-squared test, because > 20% of the cells had expected count of less than 5
  4. bvalue assumed based on knowledge on how support was organised pre-COVID-19
  5. cvalue assumed based on knowledge on how support was organised during the second COVID-19 wave
  6. dtotal calculated based on groups with valid data on this variable
  7. eonly asked to bereaved relatives (n = 90)
  8. fonly asked to bereaved relatives who said goodbye in person (n = 78)
  9. gmultiple answers possible