Skip to main content

Table 8 Summary of health consequences of falls included in decision modelsa

From: Economic models of community-based falls prevention: a systematic review with subsequent commissioning and methodological recommendations

Study label (n = 46)b

Non-MA or non-injurious fall

MA or injurious fall

Fracture

Fatal fall

Fear of falling

Fall-induced LTC admission

Excess mortality

Agartioglu (2020) [50]

ËŸ

Injury

Mixc

    

Albert (2016) [51]

ËŸ

MA

     

Alhambra-Borras (2019)d [52]

Com

Com

  

Com

  

Beard (2006) [53]

 

MA

     

BODE3 models

 

MA

 

ËŸ

   

Carande-Kulis (2015) [55]

 

MA

 

ËŸ

   

CSP (2016) [56]

ËŸ

MA

   

ËŸ

 

Church (2011); (2012) [57, 58]

ËŸ

MA

Mix

ËŸ

ËŸ

ËŸ

 

Comans (2009) [59]

ËŸ

MA

     

Day (2009); (2010) [60, 61]

ËŸ

MA

     

Eldridge (2005) [63]

ËŸ

MA

Hip

ËŸ

ËŸ

ËŸ

ËŸ

Farag (2015) [64]

ËŸ

MA

 

ËŸ

 

ËŸ

 

Franklin (2019) [65]

ËŸ

MA

 

ËŸ

 

ËŸ

ËŸ

Frick (2010) [66]

  

Hip

ËŸ

  

ËŸ

Hektoen (2009) [67]

ËŸ

Injury

Mix

    

Hiligsmann (2014) [68]

  

Mix

   

ËŸ

Hirst (2016) [69]

  

Mix

  

ËŸ

 

Honkanen (2006) [70]

  

Hip

  

ËŸ

ËŸ

Howland (2015) [71]

 

MA

     

Ippoliti (2018) [72]

  

Hip

    

Johansson (2008) [73]

  

Hip

   

ËŸ

Lee (2013) [74]

ËŸ

MA

  

ËŸ

  

Ling (2008) [75]

ËŸ

MA

   

ËŸ

 

McLean (2015) [76]

ËŸ

Injury

Mix

    

Miller (2011) [77]

ËŸ

MA

     

Mori (2017) [78]

  

Mix

  

ËŸ

ËŸ

Moriarty (2019) [79]

 

MA

Hip

  

ËŸ

ËŸ

Nshimyumukiza (2013) [80]

  

Mix

  

ËŸ

ËŸ

OMAS (2008) [81]

 

MA

Mix

ËŸ

 

ËŸ

 

Poole (2014) [83]

  

Hip

   

ËŸ

Poole (2015) [84]

 

MA

 

ËŸ

 

ËŸ

 

PHE (2018) [85]

ËŸ

MA

Mix

ËŸ

ËŸ

ËŸ

 

RCN (2005) [34]

 

MA

Hip

    

Sach (2007); (2010) [86, 87]

ËŸ

MA

     

Smith (2016) [88]

 

MA

Mix

    

Tannenbaum (2015) [89]

ËŸ

MA

Mix

ËŸ

ËŸ

 

ËŸ

Turner (2020) [90]

 

MA

Mix

ËŸ

   

Velde (2008) [91]

ËŸ

MA

     

Wu (2010) [93]

ËŸ

MA

     

Zarca (2014) [94]

  

Hip

   

ËŸ

  1. Abbreviations: BODE3 Burden of Disease Epidemiology, Equity and Cost-Effectiveness Programme studies, including Boyd (2020) [54], Deverall (2018) [62], Pega (2016) [82] and Wilson (2017) [92], Com Composite, LTC Long-term care, MA fall Fall requiring medical attention
  2. aOnly the health consequences that are explicitly incorporated by models are catalogued: i.e., studies included separate model states and probabilities for each consequence
  3. bSee Table 2 for study references; parenthesised number refers to the number of models included in the table
  4. cThe model incorporated multiple specified fracture types (e.g., hip, vertebral, wrist) or a general category of fracture without specifying the component fracture types
  5. dThis model used a composite measure of health consequences including recurrent falls, fear of falling and mobility and balance problems. Thus, the fall types and fear of falling are marked as ‘Composite’ (Com). The model also included a multivariate frailty index capturing physical, psychological and social aspects of vulnerability