Skip to main content

Table 2 Overview of the Cirrhosis Care Alberta (CCAB) evaluation methods

From: The cirrhosis care Alberta (CCAB) protocol: implementing an evidence-based best practice order set for the management of liver cirrhosis - a hybrid type I effectiveness-implementation trial

RE-AIM Domains

Outcomes

Measures

Data sources/ tools

Analytic Methods

Study Phase

1

2

3

Reach

Uptake

Proportion of care providers who participate in education interventions for the order set,

Program data, Administrative data,

Descriptive statistics

 

X

X

Proportion of cirrhosis patients being managed using the CCAB order set

Chart reviews

Effectiveness

Clinical and Cost-Utility

I.e.. Cumulative hospital LOS and readmission rates per patient year,

Administrative data,

Interrupted time series,

X

 

X

Chart reviews

Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratio

Cost of care (health system perspective) QALYs gained

Patient reported outcome measures (PROMs)

Health-related quality of life,

Post-discharge phone surveys, EQ-5D and CTM questionnaires,

Descriptive and inferential statistics,

X

 

X

Patient/family and provider experience

Framework and thematic analyses

Qualitative interviews

Quality Measures

Quality of care (eg. appropriate prescribing of rifaximin, screening for frailty, time to post discharge follow up)

Chart reviews

Interrupted time series

X

 

X

Adoption

Utilization

Number of hospital sites that use the orders sets/Number of hospital sites enrolled,

Administrative data,

Descriptive statistics,

  

X

Qualitative interviews

Framework and thematic analyses guided by NPT and CFIR

Processes and determinants of adoption

Implementation

Feasibility

Processes and determinants of feasibility and acceptability from patients, caregivers and health care providers’ perspectives

Qualitative interviews

Framework and thematic analyses guided by NPT and CFIR

X

X

X

Fidelity

Proportion of order sets prescribed that adhere to the three core-components of the standardized CCAB order set

Administrative data

Descriptive statistics

  

X

Maintenance

Sustainability

Proportion of cirrhosis patients being managed using the CCAB order set 6 months after the research team has completed supported rollout

CCAB program implementation data,

Descriptive statistics,

  

X

Framework and thematic analyses guided by NPT and CFIR

Qualitative interviews

  1. CCAB Cirrhosis Care Alberta, CFIR Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research, EQ-5D EuroQol- 5 Dimension, NPT Normalization Process Theory, Study Phases: 1 = Engagement, 2 = Preparation, 3 = Implementation