Skip to main content

Table 3 A comparison of dependent and independent variables for rural and urban respondents in the pre- and post-intervention groups

From: The spillover effect of midwife attrition from the Nigerian midwives service scheme

 

Rural respondents

Urban respondents

Characteristics

Last childbirth occurred before 2010

Last childbirth occurred between 2010 - 2011

Difference

T-test p-value

Last childbirth occurred before 2010

Last childbirth occurred between 2010 - 2011

Difference

T-test p-value

Mean age (years)

29.9

28.5

−1.4

< 0.001

30.9

29.7

−1.2

< 0.001

Average number of children ever born

4.4

4.2

− 0.2

< 0.001

3.9

3.6

−0.3

< 0.001

Mean number of years of formal education received

3.4

3.4

0.0

< 0.956

7.4

8.1

+ 0.7

< 0.001

Percentage in the middle or a lower wealth quintile

83.3

84.0

0.7

0.128

28.4

27.9

−0.5

0.532

Other characteristics

 Any antenatal visit to public-sector clinics (%)

36.1

45.5

+ 9.4

< 0.001

54.4

59.6

+ 5.2

< 0.001

 Any antenatal visit to private clinics (%)

9.2

7.6

−1.6

< 0.001

26.6

26.6

0.0

0.982

 Antenatal visits to other sites/No antenatal care

52.8

46.3

−6.5

< 0.001

18.3

13.4

−4.9

< 0.001

 Deliveries in public-sector clinics/hospitals (%)

16.3

18.0

+ 1.7

< 0.001

34.9

39.1

+ 4.3%

< 0.001

 Deliveries in private-sector clinics/hospitals (%)

7.9

6.3

−0.16

< 0.001

24.4

25.6

+ 1.1

0.162

 Deliveries at home (%)

74.7

75.4

+ 0.7

0.208

37.9

35.0

−2.9

0.001

Barriers to accessing primary healthcare services

 -those in need of permission (%)

16.4

14.7

−1.7

< 0.001

11.4

6.7

−4.7

< 0.001

 -those who couldn’t afford the cost of care (%)

63.3

52.1

−11.2

< 0.001

43.1

33.1

−10.0

< 0.001

 -those who thought the closest clinic/hospital was too far (%)

46.2

40.0

−6.3

< 0.001

20.5

15.7

−4.8

< 0.001

 -those in need of company (%)

21.2

18.1

−3.1

< 0.001

9.6

7.0

−2.6

< 0.001

 Number of observations

15,495

11,806

6224

5737

  1. The pre- and post-intervention groups made up of respondents whose most-recent birth occurred between 2003 and 2009 and 2010 – 2013 respectively. In the difference column, “+” indicates an increase, while “-” indicates a decrease. The significant reduction in barriers to accessing primary healthcare services over time may be a consequence of the MSS, or may mediate the effect of the scheme. However, we chose to leave them in the models to avoid omitted variable bias, and because our conclusions were robust to their exclusion