Table 5 Effectiveness of KT tools on primary outcome categories
From: Knowledge translation tools for parents on child health topics: a scoping review
Study design | First author (year) | Single/Multiple component KT tool groups (specific KT Tool) | Health category (topic) | Primary Outcome Categories | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patient’s knowledge | Patient’s experience | Health behaviour & health status | ||||
Cross-sectional | Dempsey (2006) | Single component (information sheet) | Public health (Vaccination) | – | no effect | – |
|  | Evans (2009) | Multi-component (video + book) | Chronic (Inherited metabolic disorders) | – | – | unclear |
Ranjit (2015) | Single component (book) | Public health (Healthy diet & physical activity) | no effect | mixed effects | no effect | |
Sustersic (2013) | Single component (pamphlet) | Acute (Gastroenteritis, tonsillitis) | – | – | mixed effects | |
Before-after | Skranes (2015) | Single component (website) | Public health (Minor child health conditions) | positive effect | no effect | – |
Controlled before-after | Scheinman (2010) | Single component (video) | Public health (Infant feeding) | mixed effects | – | mixed effects |
Taddio (2014) | Single component (pamphlet) | Acute (Procedural pain management) | no effect | – | – | |
Cohort | Nordfeldt (2002) | Multi-component (2 videos +2 pamphlets) | Chronic (Type I diabetes) | – | unclear | unclear |
Multi-component (2 pamphlets) | ||||||
RCT | Bailey (2015) | Single component (information sheet) | Acute (Surgical pain management) | positive effect | positive effect | mixed effects |
Bauchner (2001) | Multi-component (video + pamphlet) | Public health (Antibiotics use) | no effect | no effect | mixed effects | |
Christakis (2006) | Single component (tailored website) | Public health (Preventive care) | – | – | mixed effects | |
Jackson (2006) | Multi-component (5 printed activity guides + series of tip sheets for parents + series of newsletters for children) | Public health (Smoking prevention) | – | – | positive effect | |
Multi-component (5 information sheets) | ||||||
Nordfeldt (2003) | Multi-component (2 videos +2 booklets) | Chronic (Type I diabetes) | – | – | mixed effect | |
(1 video +1 booklet) | ||||||
Nordfeldt (2005) | Multi-component (2 videos +2 booklets) | Chronic (Type I diabetes) | – | – | positive effect | |
Multi-component (1 video +1 booklet) | ||||||
Reich (2010) | Multi-component (6 books) | Public health (Minor child health conditions) | mixed effects | – | – | |
Tijam (2013) | Single component (cartoon book) | Chronic (Vision impairment) | – | – | mixed effects | |
Single component (pamphlet) | ||||||
Wakimizu (2009) | Multi-component (video + booklet) | Acute (Surgery) | mixed effects | mixed effects | – | |
Wilson (2006) | Multi-component (2 pamphlets) | Public health (Vaccination) | no effect | – | – | |
| Â | Multi-component (2 information sheets) | |||||