Skip to main content

Table 2 Thematic analysis of cancer PACE meeting summaries

From: Cancer drug funding decisions in Scotland: impact of new end-of-life, orphan and ultra-orphan processes

Themes

Frequency (n = 45)

Incorporated in CEE?

Characteristics of the disease:

40

  

 Poor prognosis

 

30

~

 Heavily symptomatic

 

24

~

 Devastating impact on patient and family

 

19

x

 Patients are young

 

12

x

 Psychological impact on patient

 

10

Patient benefits of the drug:

45

  

 Tolerability

 

31

~

 Increase in overall survival

 

26

 Improved progression-free survival

 

21

 Issues with status quo treatments

 

19

 Productivity

 

18

x

 Value of extra time

 

17

 Normal life

 

17

~

 Better symptom control

 

16

 Independence

 

16

~

 Quality of life

 

15

 Reduces anxiety/gives hope

 

11

~

 Trial evidence underestimates drug benefit

 

10

Drug options and treatment pathways:

45

  

 Currently limited options

 

30

 Convenience

 

23

x

 Additional treatment option

 

14

~

 Innovative therapy

 

13

x

 No recent development in this disease

 

10

x

General issues:

27

  

 (Very) strong support for this medicine

 

14

x

 Should be made available in line with indication

 

11

x

Total comments

 

527

 
  1. Includes themes mentioned in 10 or more PACE meeting summaries
  2. √ Explicitly incorporated in cost-effectiveness evaluation (CEE); ~ Partially or indirectly incorporated; x Not incorporated