From: Interventions to prevent disability in frail community-dwelling elderly: a systematic review
1. Methodological Quality of Trials (Criteria List by Cochrane Back Review Group) |
---|
Descriptive Items |
1. Were eligibility criteria clearly specified? |
2. Were index and control interventions explicitly described? |
3. Was described whether adverse effects had or had not occurred? |
4. Was a short-term follow-up measurement (directly after the intervention) of disability performed? |
5. Was a long-term follow-up measurement (> 6 months after the intervention) of disability performed? |
Statistical Items |
6. Was the sample size for each group described? |
7. Were point estimates and measures of variability presented for disability? |
Internal Validity Items |
8. Was a method of randomization used? |
9. Was treatment allocation concealed? |
10. Were groups similar at baseline regarding the most important prognostic indicators? |
11. Were co-interventions avoided or comparable? |
12. Was the compliance acceptable in all groups? |
13. Was the outcome assessor blinded to the intervention? |
14. Was the withdrawal/dropout rate acceptable (maximum of 20% for short-term follow-up and 30% for long-term follow-up)? |
15. Was timing of the outcome assessment in both groups comparable? |
16. Did the analysis include an intention-to-treat analysis? |
2. Results of the Trial |
Disability outcome measure |
Frailty components measures |
Baseline and follow-up details: number of participants, time of follow-up and results of the analyses |