From: Decision-making regarding total knee replacement surgery: A qualitative meta-synthesis
Methods & Concepts | Sanders et al. 2004 | Toye et al. 2006 | Woolhead et al. 2002 | Hudak et al. 2002 | Figaro et al. 2004 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sample | 27 patients with hip/knee pain & disability. | 18 participants with knee osteoarthritis listed for TKR. | 25 patients on a waiting list for TKR. | 17 patients who were potential for TJA (hip or knee) – but did not want the procedure. | 94 black people aged 50 – 89 with knee osteoarthritis. |
Data Collection | In-depth interviews. | Semi-structured interviews. | In-depth Interviews. | In-depth interviews. | Semi-structured interviews. |
Setting | Survey was used to identify a sample of participants in Somerset, UK. | Patients listed for TKR at a specialist orthopedic hospital in UK. | Patients sampled from 3 orthopedic surgeon's waiting list in UK. | Participants recruited from an initial survey, conducted in Toronto, Canada. | Participants were recruited from a church or senior centre in northern Manhattan, USA. |
Concepts | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
Experience of pain | Most had experienced pain and disability for one or more decades. | Participants found it difficult to describe their pain – also reported functional loss. | Crippling and severe pain and limited mobility was identified. | _____ | ____ |
Perception of health professionals role | Did not want to bother the GP with their symptoms. | Doctor was seen as the expert. | Believed the surgeon was the expert. | Patients relied on the doctor to help them make a decision about surgery. | Doctors were seen as the gatekeepers to TKR surgery. |
Expectation of treatment | Participants assumed they would not be considered as appropriate candidates for surgery because of their age. | Most participants felt that TKR surgery was the only cure. | Participants accepted that there should be a waiting list for TKR, but felt several other factors really determine who gets TKR (i.e. weight & age). | Participants believed they needed to be in constant pain and unable to move before they would consider surgery. | Most patients expressed the belief that their body should remain intact and they did not want surgery. |
Expectation of condition | Participants perceived their symptoms as associated with normal aging. | Participants believed their OA would only get worse | _____ | Participants had the expectation of pain with age. | OA was natural, inevitable, a sign of aging or deterioration. |
Social Context & social support | ______ | A person's social network was an important factor in constructing the need for TKR. | _____ | Participants often drew on lay sources of TJA information. | ______ |
Comparison with others | ____ | ____ | Believed that there are people worse off than them and they should have priority for surgery. | Participants believed that there are people worse off than them. | Patients believed the economic status of blacks & whites was the reason black people did not have TKR. |
Coping strategies | Relied on over the counter medications and exercise to relieve pain. | ______ | ____ | _____ | Belief in god was important with regard to the outcome of surgery. |
Second order Interpretation | Patients viewed their symptoms as a natural part of aging, and were reluctant to seek care or have surgery. | Patients make decisions about surgery based on their perception of symptoms, and depending on their life environment. | Patients have the perception that "there are probably people worse off" and they should have priority for surgery. | "The taken for granted assumption that one needs to be in constant pain and virtually unable to move before seriously considering surgery". | Participants had negative perceptions of TKR, because of the risks they associated with surgery. |
Methods & Concepts | Marcinowski et al. 2005 | Sjoling et al. 2004 | Showalter et al. 2000 | Woolhead et al. 2005 | Clark et al. 2004 |
Sample | 9 patients who had TKR – but had been waiting for up to 2 years. | 9 patients after TKR, 9 patients on waiting list for hip replacement. | 5 TJA patients and their spouses after surgery. | 25 patients 3 months before TKR – 10 interviewed 6 months after TKR. | 17 patients who were potential for TJA (hip or knee) – but they did not want the procedure. |
Data Collection | Un-structured interviews | Un-structured Interviews. | 1 focus group – to discuss their needs prior to and following TJA surgery. | In-depth interviews. | In-depth interviews. |
Setting | Participants were contacted with a letter after surgery in a hospital in New Zealand. | Participants were recruited at a hospital in Sweden. | Participants recruited by telephone (were already scheduled for follow up visit) in USA. | Patients sampled from 3 orthopedic surgeon's waiting list in UK. | Participants recruited from an initial survey, conducted in Toronto, Canada. |
Concepts | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
Experience of pain | Living in constant pain & hurting with everyday activities. | Pain is described as dreadful and extremely disabling. | Still felt extreme pain after surgery. | Still had continued pain and immobility after surgery | Participants viewed their pain as bad, but not "'bad enough" for surgery. |
Perception of health professionals role | Had a powerful faith in health professionals. | Needed to establish a trusting relationship with the doctor. | Nurses and physicians were acknowledged as important sources of information & support. | Participants did not criticise the surgeon or the surgery. | Participants wanted more information from their health care provider. |
Expectation of treatment | Some viewed surgery as the only way to carry on leading a normal life. | ______ | Believed they would be back to normal (walking, dancing) at 56 weeks. | Patients acknowledged that TKR was major surgery and it was natural to feel pain. | Participants were concerned about the efficacy of TKR surgery. |
Expectation of condition | ______ | ______ | _____ | ______ | Participants perceived pain as natural, expected with old age. |
Social Context & social support | Participants revealed that "accepting help" was a condition necessary to maintaining independence in the long run. | Having a sense of underlying support (friends & family) helped preserve continuity. | Spousal support was important during the recovery process. | Participant's perception of outcome was related to certain situations in their life (i.e. moving from a lonely neighbourhood). | Patients drew on lay sources of information. |
Comparison with others | _____ | _____ | _____ | Felt the outcome was good when they compared themselves to others worse off than them. | Relied on accounts from others who had undergone TJA surgery |
Coping strategies | Having faith and a positive attitude (stoicism) allowed participants to endure the pain. | Respondents preserve the sense of living a full life by contending with what they could do. | Participants had to make adjustments to their home (putting on socks, going to bathroom) to cope after surgery. | _____ | Participants 'accommodated' the pain, by making adjustments and coping. |
Second order Interpretation | Determination, optimism, and trust sustained participants through the entire TKJA process. | Participants "put their trust in surgery to alleviate their suffering, but find it hard to live in the uncertainty inflicted by the indeterminate waiting time". | "Preparing spouses for the role changes that occur following surgery could help patients and spouses establish realistic expectations of the recovery process". | The TKR outcome was viewed positively or negatively when viewed in relation to the participant's life context or environment. | "Symptoms and information sources were the two main factors influencing patient decision making". |