Skip to main content

Table 1 Descriptive statistics on sample hospitals and inpatients before and after the information disclosure

From: Does information disclosure among public hospitals stimulate medical cost change efforts? A pilot study in Shanghai

 

Total

(N = 14 hospitals)

 

Thyroid malignant tumors

(N = 12 hospitals)

 

Colorectal malignant tumors

(N = 12 hospitals)

 

Before

After

 

Before

After

Hospital characteristics

       

 Hospital type, No. (%)

       

  General

13 (92.86)

 

11 (91.67)

11 (91.67)

 

11 (91.67)

11 (91.67)

  Specialty

1 (7.14)

 

1 (8.33)

1 (8.33)

 

1 (8.33)

1 (8.33)

 No. of beds, mean (SD)

1,630 (324.78)

 

1,426 (346.83)

1,665 (297.98)

 

1,473 (358.99)

1,683(351.45)

 No. of employees, mean (SD)

3,139 (778.90)

 

2,815 (636.91)

3,300 (786.56)

 

2,870 (690.26)

3,200 (834.40)

 Annual discharges per hospital, mean (SD)

88,964(23916.28)

 

66,953(18613.51)

97,255(25698.80)

 

67,553 (20348.88)

95,329 (28035.22)

 Annual costs per hospital [RMB, million], mean (SD)

3366.73 (1095.90)

 

2369.51 (596.22)

3833.67 (1203.73)

 

2356.53 (670.24)

3688.83 (1288.02)

 Length of stay [days], mean (SD)

7.23 (0.60)

 

8.62 (1.48)

6.82 (0.61)

 

8.66 (1.48)

6.89 (0.68)

Inpatient characteristics

       

 Cases with targeted diseases, No.

218,928

 

14,246

106,517

 

13,241

84,924

Proportion of cases with targeted diseases [‰], mean (SD)

  

11.47 (16.53)

13.38 (15.18)

 

9.87 (7.18)

10.57 (7.22)

 Costs per case with targeted diseases [RMB], mean (SD)

  

15144.22 (2957.82)

17927.70 (3000.38)

 

49761.75(10052.56)

57772.37 (13076.74)

 Proportion of costs on targeted diseases [‰], mean (SD)

  

3.62 (5.59)

6.94 (7.59)

 

12.11 (5.99)

14.30 (7.70)

Drug costs per case with targeted diseases [RMB], mean (SD)

  

3464.79 (1659.31)

3022.68 (1283.89)

 

18313.48 (6880.50)

15637.21 (7036.72)

Consumable costs per case with targeted diseases [RMB], mean (SD)

  

1692.70 (996.64)

2833.43 (1195.23)

 

15774.99 (3579.57)

18740.66 (7328.66)

Length of stay per case with targeted diseases [days], mean (SD)

  

6.99 (1.79)

5.78 (1.53)

 

20.57 (3.62)

16.64 (4.29)

Subgroup characteristics by quartiles

       

 Costs per case with targeted diseases [RMB], mean (SD)

       

  Q1 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

11791.28 (982.53)

16746.42 (2363.21)

 

40886.50 (5792.59)

48662.94 (8830.17)

  Q2 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

14005.46 (1432.52)

16756.35 (2707.67)

 

44275.03 (8009.01)

49967.12 (5722.54)

  Q3 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

16239.06 (1446.63)

18096.45 (2083.61)

 

57314.29 (7145.93)

61073.73 (7837.33)

  Q4 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

18541.10 (2157.90)

20111.56 (3379.42)

 

56571.17 (6907.53)

71385.67(13184.09)

 Drug costs per case with targeted diseases [RMB], mean (SD)

       

  Q1 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

1897.46 (476.05)

2218.30 (580.55)

 

11242.36 (4333.24)

11807.70 (5355.19)

  Q2 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

2738.45 (807.37)

2415.93 (779.79)

 

15639.95 (4364.58)

10311.13 (3440.44)

  Q3 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

4104.58 (1899.78)

3579.18 (1354.04)

 

22927.88 (3477.73)

17947.10 (5510.08)

  Q4 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

5118.69 (709.41)

3877.32 (1339.61)

 

23443.73 (6045.40)

22482.90 (5709.41)

 Consumable costs per case with targeted diseases [RMB], mean (SD)

       

  Q1 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

1121.72 (115.35)

2483.72 (940.43)

 

5.11 (1.61)

4.91 (1.69)

  Q2 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

1045.42 (310.01)

2601.85 (1106.94)

 

7.62 (1.67)

5.19 (1.30)

  Q3 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

2409.11 (1101.24)

2594.85 (1138.65)

 

7.49 (1.32)

6.95 (0.91)

  Q4 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

2194.55 (1102.01)

3653.29 (1201.56)

 

7.75 (1.09)

6.05 (1.22)

 Length of stay per case with targeted diseases [days], mean (SD)

       

  Q1 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

14548.55 (3441.16)

16231.39 (2913.19)

 

17.41 (2.30)

14.22 (2.32)

  Q2 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

15191.99 (1754.77)

18416.43 (3149.26)

 

18.73 (3.36)

12.89 (2.38)

  Q3 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

15537.67 (3611.85)

18811.05 (8735.23)

 

22.40 (2.43)

19.37 (4.08)

  Q4 subgroup of hospitals (N = 3)

  

17821.77 (4337.62)

21503.77 (10385.53)

 

23.76 (1.92)

20.06 (2.67)

  1. Notes: “Before” represents the overall level from 1st quarter of 2012 to 3rd quarter of 2013, “After” represents the overall level from 4th quarter of 2013 to 3rd quarter of 2020; Quartile 1 (Q1) subgroup represents hospitals with the lowest costs per case at 4th quarter of 2013, Q4 subgroup represents hospitals with the highest costs per case at 4th quarter of 2013