Skip to main content

Table 3 The CVR, CVI and modified Kappa for each item

From: Non-hospital healthcare center’s preparedness assessment toolbar for providing basic emergency care: a sequential exploratory mixed-method study

The CVR, CVI and modified Kappa for each item

Sub-domains and Items

Essential

Relevance

Clarity

Nea

CVRb

Interpretation

Number giving rating of 3 or 4 to relevancy of item

CVIc

p cd

Modified Kappa (Modified CVI)

Number giving rating of 3 or 4 to clarity of item

CVI

p c

Modified Kappa (Modified CVI)

S-d 1: Environmental Infrastructures of the Centers

 S-d 1–1

9

0.80

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 1–2

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 1–3

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 1–4

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

S-d 2: Protocols, Guidelines and Policies

 S-d 2–1

9

0.80

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 2–2

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 2–3

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 2–4

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 2–5

9

0.8

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 2–6

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 2–7

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

S-d 3: Medical Supplies and Equipment

 S-d 3–1

10

0.80

Remained

6

0.75

0.109

0.71

6

0.85

0.054

0.84

 S-d 3–2

10

1

Remained

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 3–3

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

 S-d 3–4

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–5

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–6

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–7

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–8

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–9

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–10

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–11

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–12

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–13

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–14

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–15

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–16

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–17

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.88

 S-d 3–18

9

0.8

Remained

7

1

0.007

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

 S-d 3–19

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 3–20

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–21

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–22

10

1

Remained

7

1

0.007

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–23

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–24

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–25

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–26

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–27

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–28

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 3–29

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–30

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–31

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–32

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

7

1

0.007

1

 S-d 3–33

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–34

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–35

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–36

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 3–37

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 3–38

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–39

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–40

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–41

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–42

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 3–43

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–44

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

6

0.75

0.109

0.71

 S-d 3–45

10

1

Remained

6

0.75

0.109

0.71

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–46

10

1

Remained

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

6

0.75

0.109

0.71

 S-d 3–47

10

1

Remained

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

 S-d 3–48

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

6

0.75

0.109

0.71

 S-d 3–49

10

1

Remained

5

0.71

0.164

0.65

6

0.66

0.164

0.6

 S-d 3–50

10

1

Remained

6

0.66

0.164

0.6

5

0.71

0.164

0.65

 S-d 3–51

9

0.8

Remained

6

0.66

0.164

0.6

6

0.66

0.164

0.6

 S-d 3–52

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–53

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

6

0.75

0.109

0.71

 S-d 3–54

10

1

Remained

5

0.71

0.164

0.65

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 3–55

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

7

1

0.007

1

 S-d 3–56

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 3–57

10

1

Remained

6

0.75

0.109

0.71

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

 S-d 3–58

10

1

Remained

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

7

0.87

0.031

0.87

S-d 4: Human Resources

 S-d 4–1

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 4–2

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 4–3

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

1

0.001

1

S-d 5: Emergency Medicines

 S-d 5–1

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–2

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 5–3

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–4

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 5–5

4

−0.2

Eliminated

 S-d 5–6

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–7

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–8

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 5–9

9

0.8

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 5–10

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–11

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–12

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–13

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–14

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–15

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 5–16

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–17

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 5–18

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–19

9

0.8

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 5–20

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 5–21

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–22

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–23

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–24

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–25

9

0.8

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–26

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–27

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–28

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 5–29

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 5–30

10

1

Remained

7

1

0.007

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 5–31

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

S-d 6: Providing Clinical Services For Resuscitation

 S-d 6–1

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 6–2

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 6–3

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 6–4

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 6–5

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 6–6

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 6–7

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 6–8

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

 S-d 6–9

10

1

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 6–10

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 6–11

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 6–12

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

S-d 7: Clinical Interventions For Specific Injuries

 S-d 7–1

4

−0.2

Eliminated

        

 S-d 7–2

7

0.4

Eliminated

        

 S-d 7–3

7

0.4

Eliminated

        

 S-d 7–4

2

−0.6

Eliminated

        

 S-d 7–5

7

0.4

Eliminated

        

 S-d 7–6

4

−0.2

Eliminated

        

S-d 8: Medicine Storage Capability

 S-d 8–1

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 8–2

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

 S-d 8–3

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 8–4

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

 S-d 8–5

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 8–6

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

S-d 9: Maintenance of Equipment

 S-d 9–1

9

0.8

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 9–2

10

1

Remained

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

8

0.88

0.017

0.87

 S-d 9–3

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

1

0.001

1

S-d 10: Management Process

 S-d 10–1

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 10–2

10

1

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 10–3

9

0.8

Remained

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

8

0.88

0.017

0.88

 S-d 10–4

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

 S-d 10–5

9

0.8

Remained

9

1

0.001

1

9

1

0.001

1

 S-d 10–6

10

1

Remained

9

0.9

0.009

0.89

8

0.8

0.043

0.79

  1. NOTE:aNumber of experts evaluated the item essential
  2. bCVR or Content Validity Ratio = (Ne-N/2)/(N/2) with 10 person at the expert panel (N = 10), the items with the CVR bigger than 0.62 remained at the instrument and the rest eliminated
  3. cCVI or Content Validity Index
  4. dpc (probability of a chance occurrence) was computed using the formula: pc = [N! /A! (N -A)!]