Skip to main content

Table 1 Final list of consented ICU discharge criteria

From: Delphi study to derive expert consensus on a set of criteria to evaluate discharge readiness for adult ICU patients to be discharged to a general ward—European perspective

 

Final list of ICU discharge criteria

Fit for ICU discharge

Needs further intensive care therapy / monitoring

Value calculation method to evaluate discharge readiness

Criterion importance rank

Exceptions when "mandatory to be met"

Respiratory system

 1

Is the patient's (own / artificial) airway patent?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits

 2

Is the cough effective in a way, that the patient can be handled at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits, p. with low level of consciousness and requiring long-term artificial airway aspiration

 3

Blood oxygenation: Stable SpO2 (≥ 92% OR stable around lower patient individual baseline value) AND patient is breathing on room air?

yes

no

Worst value must be above threshold value AND trend must be stable over defined time frame

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits, p. with chronic lung disease

 4

Respiratory rate: Stable RR trend with 10 ≤ resp ≤ 30 (pm)

OR patient's individual baseline value is met?

yes

no

Worst value must be within acceptable range AND trend must be stable over defined time frame

mandatory to be met

EOL-care

 5

If further respiratory support is needed, feasible at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 6

If the patient is in need of tracheal suctioning, feasible at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 7

If the patient is in need of long-term tracheostomy, could adequate care be provided at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

If patient is sufficiently trained and capable to take care of the tracheostomy

Cardiovascular system

 8

Heart rate: Stable HR trend with 50 ≤ hr ≤ 110 (bpm) OR patient's individual baseline value is met?

yes

no

Worst value must be within acceptable range AND trend must be stable over defined time frame

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits, pre-existing bradycardia

 9

Cardiac rhythm: Stable cardiac rhythm OR tolerable intermittent arrhythmia over defined time frame?

yes

no

Trend must be stable over defined time frame

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits, p. has intermittent AF but is otherwise hemodynamically stable with controlled ventricular response

 10

Mean arterial pressure: Stable MAP trend with 60 < map ≤ 110 (mmHg)

OR patient's individual baseline value is met?

yes

no

Worst value must be within acceptable range AND trend must be stable over defined time frame

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits

 11

Hypervolemia / hypovolemia: Does the current volemia status require ICU monitoring?

no

yes

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 12

Hemoglobin value stable over defined time frame?

yes

no

Trend must be stable over defined time frame

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits

 13

Significant active bleeding or high risk of significant bleeding?

no

yes

n.a

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits

 14

If the patient needs continued monitoring at the receiving unit, are required technology / staff capabilities in place?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 15

If the patient carries a percutaneous transient pacemaker, could that be handled at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 16

If low-dose vasoactives are in use, is the patient manageable at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

Central nervous system

 17

Can the neurological status of the patient be adequately handled and monitored at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

Pain

 18

Pain therapy sufficient and feasible at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

Urogenital system

 19

Do urine output, electrolyte level, and renal function allow patient discharge?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits

 20

If required, renal replacement therapy possible outside the ICU?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits

Fluid loss and drainages

 21

Could fluid loss or drainage(s) be monitored and handled adequately at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

Medication and nutrition

 22

If the patient needs continuous IV application (e.g. Insulin, glucose, antibiotics, vasopressors, nutrition), allowed and feasible at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

Patient diagnosis, prognosis and preferences

 23

Patient's preference is to stop intensive care therapy and to leave the ICU

yes

no

n.a

not mandatory to be met

 

 24

Therapeutic susceptibility: Patient doesn't benefit from ICU care anymore and negative effects may outweigh

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

Institution specific criteria

 25

Patient no longer meets ICU admission criteria and meets admission criteria for a lower level of care

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 26

Do current acuity and dependency levels and current workload at the receiving unit allow to admit and take care of this patient?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 27

If the patient is immune-compromised or infectious, could the patient be handled and adequately cared for at the receiving unit?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

 

 28

If discharge at night or weekend can't be avoided, are measures in place to protect patient safety?

yes

no

n.a

mandatory to be met

EOL-care, agreed treatment limits, priotarisation against patients with greater need for intensive care