Table 9 Included articles discussing health from a philosophical perspective
From: Concepts of health in different contexts: a scoping review
Authors, year | Country | Article type/ study design | Perspective (theoretical approach) | Subthemes of Concept of health | Subthemes of Dimensions of health |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Included articles discussing health from a social science perspective | |||||
Bauer et al., 2020 [55] | Switzerland, Canada, Kenya, Italy, United Kingdom, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Spain, Israel, Austria, Singapore, Netherlands, | Literature study | Salutogenic | ||
Bircher & Kuruvilla, 2014 [3] | Switzerland | Multi-grounded theory method | Multi-grounded theory | Wellbeing, adapting to change, multi-sided | Environmental, individual, social |
Cloninger et al., 2012 [56] | USA | Literature study | Holistic | Multi-sided, adapting to change | |
de Araújo et al. 2012 [57] | Brazil | Theoretical study | Hermeneutics | Subjective, adapting to change | |
Elliot, 2016 [58] | United Kingdom | Literature study | Eudaimonistic | Multi-sided | |
Ereshefsky, 2009 [59] | Canada | Paper | Naturalist/ normativist | Physical, mental | |
Haverkamp et al., 2018 [7] | The Netherlands | Practice-oriented review | Philosophical | ||
Huber et al. 2011 [5] | The Netherlands | Analysis | Positive health | Adapting to change, self-management | Physical, mental, social |
Leonardi, 2018 [1] | Italy | Literature study | Epistemological | Self-management, adapting to change, daily functioning | |
Misselbrook, 2014 [60] | Bahrain | Note | Human flourishing | Satisfying life, adapting to change | |
Misselbrook, 2016 [61] | Bahrain | Literature study | Human flourishing | Satisfying life, multi-sided, adapting to change | Physical, mental, social, spiritual, others |
Prinsen & Terwee, 2019 [15] | The Netherlands | Mixed-method study including a literature search, a qualitative and quantitative ranking study, followed by a content validity study | Positive health | ||
Reed, 2019 [62] | USA | Review | Philosophical | Subjective, satisfying life | Physical, social |
Van Spijk, 2015 [63] | Switzerland | Scientific contribution | Philosophical anthropology | Satisfying life | |
Sturmberg et al., 2010 [17] | Australia/USA | Literature study | Philosophical | Subjective, adapting to change, multi-sided | Physical, mental, social, functional |
Sturmberg, 2014 [64] | Australia | Commentary | Philosophical | Adapting to change | |
Tengland, 2016 [65] | Sweden | Critical discussion | Holistic/ capability approach | Subjective, wellbeing, multi-sided | Environmental |
Tyreman, 2011 [66] | United Kingdom | Literature study | Phenomenological/ hermeneutics | Multi-sided, subjective, adapting to change, participation | |
Venkatapuram, 2013 [4] | United Kingdom | Debate | Capability approach | Daily functioning, subjective, satisfying life | |
Included articles discussing health from a biomedical science perspective | |||||
Boorse, 2011 [67] | USA | Conceptual analysis | Naturalist | Complete wellbeing or functioning | |
Boorse, 2014 [68] | USA | Reactions to critics | Naturalist | Complete wellbeing or functioning | |
Hafen, 2016 [16] | Switzerland | Sociological systems theory | Health/health impairment-continuum | Complete wellbeing or functioning | |
Schroeder, 2013 [69] | United Kingdom | Literature study | Comparative | Daily functioning | |