Skip to main content

Table 2 Data from baseline survey: characteristics of total cohort, patients with follow-up data available, follow-up non-participants (total), patients who died prior to intended follow-up, and follow-up non-participants excluding patients who died

From: Emergency department consultations for respiratory symptoms revisited: exploratory investigation of longitudinal trends in patients’ perspective on care, health care utilization, and general and mental health, from a multicenter study in Berlin, Germany

Variable

Measure

Total cohort

Follow-up sub-cohort

Follow-up non-participants (total)

Follow-up non-participants who died

Follow-up non-participants, excl. patients who died

Participants

n

472

329

143

15

128

Demographics

Age

n

472

329

143

15

128

Mean (SD)

53.6 (19.2)

54.6 (18.3)

51.3 (21.0)

79.7 (7.1)

48.0 (19.5)

Median (Range)

55.0 (18–96)

56.0 (18–92)

51.0 (18–96)

81.0 (67–92)

46.0 (18–96)

Sex

n

472

329

143

15

128

  Male

%

53.2

52.9

53.8

73.3

51.6

  Female

%

46.8

47.1

46.2

26.7

48.4

Migration and travel

n

466

326

140

15

125

  Migrant first generation

%

21.9

17.2

32.9

6.7

36.0

  Second generation

%

6.9

6.1

8.6

0.0

9.6

  Tourist

%

4.3

1.2

11.4

0.0

12.8

Education (CASMIN)

n

463

325

138

15

123

  Low

%

25.5

23.7

29.7

73.3

24.4

  Intermediate

%

43.6

46.8

36.2

20.0

38.2

  High

%

30.9

29.5

34.1

6.7

37.4

ED consultation

Means of arrival

n

462

319

143

15

128

  Walk-in

%

63.0

60.2

69.2

26.7

74.2

  EMS

%

30.7

31.7

28.7

73.3

23.4

  Ambulance transport

%

6.3

8.2

2.1

0.0

2.3

Initiation of visit

n

465

325

140

15

125

  Self-referred

%

62.8

59.4

70.7

60.0

72.0

  Health professional

%

37.2

40.6

29.3

40.0

28.0

Triage category

n

456

317

139

14

125

  Lower urgency

%

41.9

40.4

45.3

0.0

50.4

  Higher urgency

%

58.1

59.6

54.7

100.0

49.6

Time of presentation

n

472

329

143

15

128

  Out-of-hours visit

%

17.2

16.7

18.2

33.3

16.4

  During office hours

%

82.8

83.3

81.8

66.7

83.6

ED symptoms

Symptom novelty

n

467

326

141

15

126

  New symptoms

%

36.4

37.7

33.3

0.0

37.3

  Recurrent symptoms

%

63.6

62.3

66.7

100.0

62.7

Symptom-associated distress

n

442

312

130

  

Mean (SD)

7.2 (1.8)

7.3 (1.8)

7.0 (1.9)

7.4 (1.9)

6.9 (1.9)

Median (Range)

7.5 (1.5–10)

7.5 (2.0–10)

7.0 (1.5–10)

8.0 (3.5–9.5)

7.0 (1.5–10)

Chronic conditions and care

Chronic pulmonary condition

n

467

326

141

15

126

yes: %

58.7

62.0

51.1

66.7

49.2

Multimorbidity

n

465

325

140

15

125

yes: %

53.5

58.8

41.4

73.3

37.6

Attached to GP

n

464

323

141

15

126

yes: %

86.6

90.7

77.3

100.0

74.6

Mental and general health

PHQ-4 anxiety subscale

n

467

326

141

15

126

Mean (SD)

1.7 (1.9)

1.6 (1.8)

2.0 (2.0)

1.8 (2.1)

2.0 (2.0)

Median (Range)

1.0 (0–6)

1.0 (0–6)

1.0 (0–6)

1.0 (0–6)

1.0 (0–6)

PHQ-4 depression subscale

n

467

326

141

15

126

Mean (SD)

2.2 (2.2)

2.1 (2.1)

2.4 (2.3)

2.7 (2.3)

2.3 (2.3)

Median (Range)

2.0 (0–6)

2.0 (0–6)

2.0 (0–6)

3.0 (0–6)

2.0 (0–6)

General life satisfaction

n

457

321

136

15

121

Mean (SD)

6.9 (2.6)

7.1 (2.5)

6.7 (2.8)

6.4 (3.1)

6.7 (2.8)

Median (Range)

8.0 (0–10)

8.0 (0–10)

8.0 (0–10)

8.0 (0–10)

8.0 (0–10)

General health

n

466

325

141

15

126

Mean (SD)

45.9 (25.0)

45.8 (24.6)

46.1 (25.9)

33.2 (23.3)

47.6 (25.8)

Median (Range)

50.0 (0–100)

50.0 (0–100)

50.0 (0–100)

40.0 (0–80.0)

50.0 (0–100)

ED visit outcomes

Diagnoses

n

472

329

143

15

128

  Pneumonia J12-J18

%

23.3

25.8

17.5

26.7

16.4

  COPD and chronic bronchitis J40-J44

%

34.3

38.3

25.2

60.0

21.1

  Asthma bronchiale J45-J46

%

9.7

8.8

11.9

0.0

13.3

  Other respiratory tract infection J09-J11, J20-J22

%

8.5

8.5

8.4

0.0

9.4

  Upper airway conditions J0x/J3x

%

10.2

8.2

14.7

0.0

16.4

  Respiratory symptom diagnosis only (R section code)

%

14.4

14.0

15.4

13.3

15.6

  Respiratory failure J96

%

19.5

20.7

16.8

46.7

13.3

Visit consequence

n

472

329

143

15

128

  Outpatients

%

61.2

58.4

67.8

20.0

73.4

  Hospital admission

%

38.8

41.6

32.2

80.0

26.6

  1. n Cases with available data for respective characteristic, % Percentage of cases with available data; Ranges reported with median values refer to minimum and maximum; Migration and travel: first generation = not born in Germany, second generation = participant born in Germany and mother/father (or both) born in another country; Education: CASMIN Comparative Analysis of Social Mobility in Industrial Nations scale, trichotomized; Triage category: MTS categories 4 and 5 = lower urgency, categories 1,2 and 3 = higher urgency; Time of presentation: out-of-hours defined as between 6 pm and 8 am on weekdays, plus weekends and Wednesdays afternoons after 2 pm; Subjective symptom-associated distress, general life satisfaction: 0–10 scales; Chronic pulmonary condition: if either self-reported or documented in hospital records; Multimorbidity = two or more self-reported chronic conditions; PHQ-4 anxiety and depression: 0–6 subscales; General health: 0–100 visual analogue scale; Diagnoses: ICD-10 codes, multiple diagnoses possible for individual cases