PICO | Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria | Search Strategy (MeSH terms and keywords) for PubMed |
---|---|---|---|
Population | Any type of health care organization | Non- health organization | hospitals[MeSH Terms] hospital department[MeSH Terms] health[MeSH Terms] |
Intervention | Performance assessment of health care organizations through implementing BSC | Studies that used other TQM tools such as MBNQA, ISO, SQA, six-sigma, etc. | “quality indicators, health care”[MeSH Terms] scorecard*[Text Word] “score card*”[Text Word] |
Comparator | -Initiation of BSC implementation (at least one year of implementation) -Or: Comparing 2 measurements after BSC implementation for at least one year -Or: Gross change/ difference after at least one year of implementation | - Initiation of BSC implementation was in less than one year. -Gross change/ difference after less than one year -One-time measurement with no comparability. | No limitation was set in the search strategy, studies that measured BSC impact within less than one year of implementation were excluded after carefully examining the full texts. |
Outcome | -Impact on financial indicators: profitability/loss, change in total revenues, change in total cost, ROI, ROA either in currency or in percentage. -Or: Impact on the patient satisfaction rate -Or: Impact on the HCWs’ satisfaction rate -The impact should be objective and measured/ quantitative. | -Impact on other indicators. -Number of patient complaints -HCWs’ burnout or turnover rate. -Cost/case or revenue/case change -Qualitative or subjective impact, for example: the managers’ opinions in impact | patient satisfaction[MeSH Terms] cost-benefit analysis[MeSH Terms] health care costs[MeSH Terms] Hospital personnel management[MeSH Terms] staff development[MeSH Terms] knowledge management[MeSH Terms] efficiency, organizational[MeSH Terms] |
Study design | All study designs | _ | No limitation regarding study design, type, or time was set in the search strategy |