Skip to main content

Table 5 Respondent Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria by Data Collection Method

From: Evaluating implementation effectiveness and sustainability of a maternity waiting homes intervention to improve access to safe delivery in rural Zambia: a mixed-methods protocol

Method

Respondents

Inclusion Criteria

Exclusion Criteria

MWH Experience Survey

Recent users of the MWH

• Mother utilizing the maternity home for at least 3 consecutive nights

• Mother utilizing the home for maternal health services (ANC, labor or PNC visit)

• Currently pregnant or under 6-weeks post-partum

• >/= 15 years of age (emancipated minor)

• Has responded to the survey at a previous visit for the same maternal health services (ANC, labor or PNC)

• Utilizing the home for reasons unrelated to maternal health

• Unwilling or unable to provide informed consent

In-Depth Interviews

MWH Governance Committee & Management Unit

Members; IGA Officer and SMAG Tailor

• Is a current governance committee/management unit member at an intervention site OR is responsible for overseeing MWH operations at a control site OR is an IGA Officer OR is a SMAG

• Is capable of responding to the domains

• >/= 18 years of age

• Is not currently affiliated with governance or management of MWH any of the study sites

• Unwilling or unable to provide informed consent

Focus Group Discussions

Pregnant or RDW, Male with child < 1 year, Elders/mother in-law (MIL), SMAGs or other potential SMAG member including traditional birth attendant (TBA), community health worker (CHW), or any individual currently volunteering at the health centre in an MCH capacity

• Respondent is a SMAG member or other potential SMAG member including TBA, CHW, or any individual currently volunteering at the health centre in an MCH capacity, Elder or MIL in a study catchment area

• Or is a pregnant woman or with a child under the age of 1

• Or is a male with a child under the age of 1,

• >/= 15 years of age

• Has previously participated in a FGD in the same year at another site or in another category (i.e.: SMAG and recently delivered)

• Is not currently affiliated with any of the study sites

• Unwilling or unable to provide informed consent

IDI with Health Facility/System staff

Health Facility Staff and Health System Staff

• Is a current health facility staff member at any one of the study sites (intervention, control, CEMONC)

• Is knowledgeable in maternal health capacity at the health facility

• Or is knowledgeable in health facility financial records

• Or is a district or provincial health officer in the study districts

• >/= 18 years of age

• Is not currently affiliated with any of the study sites

• Unwilling or unable to provide informed consent

Record Review

User of the health system/MWH

• Is recorded in MWH Register, Others Register or Activity Log between January 2016 – December 2018.

• Is recorded in BEmONC facility-based data: Delivery Register, Maternity Ward Admission Register, Postnatal Care Register, Facility Transfer Log, Ante-natal care register (where applicable) and other improvised registers as necessary between January 2016 – December 2018.

• Was recorded in MWH or health facility registers before January 2016 or after December 2018