Skip to main content

Table 2 Mean PCMC Scores for Full Scale, Change Package and Non-Change Package Indicators, and Sub-Domains, by Light Touch/Intensive groups and survey rounda

From: A comparison of intensive vs. light-touch quality improvement interventions for maternal health in Uttar Pradesh, India

 

Baseline

Endline

Light-Touch

Intensive

Light-Touch

Intensive

N

Mean

SD

N

Mean

SD

N

Mean

SD

N

Mean

SD

Total PCMC score

 PCMC total sum (23 indicators)

300

63.42

(11.44)

285

85.02

(8.12)

300

87.47

(8.31)

300

97.13

(2.91)

 Change Package PCMC total sum (8 indicators)

300

42.71

(16.15)

285

69.36

(12.56)

300

83.36

(13.51)

300

95.4

(7.61)

 Non-Change Package total sum (19 items)

300

68.65

(11.87)

285

91.23

(8.69)

300

88.81

(8.57)

300

98.05

(2.14)

 Dignity and Respect domain subtotal (5 indicators)

300

77.42

(15.65)

285

94.41

(9.93)

300

85.33

(10.75)

300

98.22

(3.63)

 Communication and Autonomy domain subtotal (7 indicators)

300

40.98

(16.24)

285

78.56

(13.06)

300

84.67

(16.19)

300

96.89

(5.37)

 Supportive Care domain subtotal (11 indicators)

300

71.33

(11.57)

285

84.87

(9.82)

300

90.22

(7.24)

300

96.78

(3.00)

Specific Indicators

Dignity and Respect Domain

  Treated with respectb

300

2.14

(0.76)

285

2.95

(0.28)

300

2.68

(0.53)

300

3

(0.00)

  Visual privacy

300

1.64

(1.01)

285

2.44

(1.17)

300

2.77

(0.53)

300

2.99

(0.17)

  Record confidentialityb

300

2.18

(0.90)

285

2.8

(0.64)

300

1.53

(1.18)

300

2.76

(0.51)

  Verbal abuseb

300

2.69

(0.68)

285

2.98

(0.17)

300

2.89

(0.49)

300

2.99

(0.11)

  Physical abuseb

300

2.96

(0.27)

285

3

(0.00)

300

2.92

(0.46)

300

3

(0.00)

Communication and Autonomy Domain

  Introduce self

300

0.09

(0.30)

285

0.36

(0.97)

300

1.87

(1.11)

300

2.61

(0.74)

  Involvement in careb

300

1.08

(1.11)

285

2.82

(0.52)

300

2.49

(0.76)

300

2.93

(0.25)

  Delivery position choice

300

1.22

(1.11)

285

2.81

(0.63)

300

2.92

(0.34)

300

2.91

(0.36)

  Languageb

300

2.45

(0.78)

285

2.62

(0.88)

300

2.76

(0.48)

300

2.97

(0.17)

  Explain exams/proceduresb

300

0.68

(0.91)

285

2.83

(0.49)

300

2.49

(0.77)

300

2.94

(0.24)

  Explain medicinesb

300

1.06

(1.24)

285

2.21

(1.19)

300

2.57

(0.72)

300

3

(0.06)

  Able to ask questionsb

300

2.02

(0.91)

285

2.85

(0.55)

300

2.68

(0.51)

300

2.98

(0.15)

Supportive Care Domain

  Time to careb

300

2.44

(0.78)

285

3

(0.00)

300

2.84

(0.43)

300

2.91

(0.30)

  Labor supportb

300

2.75

(0.57)

285

2.89

(0.41)

300

2.96

(0.20)

300

3

(0.00)

  Delivery supportb

300

2.72

(0.60)

285

2.92

(0.42)

300

2.98

(0.14)

300

3

(0.00)

  Attention when need helpb

300

1.98

(0.80)

285

2.85

(0.47)

300

2.65

(0.49)

300

2.99

(0.10)

  Bribesb

300

2.28

(0.71)

285

1.35

(1.24)

300

2.65

(0.68)

300

2.55

(0.60)

  Control painb

300

1.61

(0.80)

285

2.45

(1.03)

300

2.68

(0.48)

300

2.95

(0.22)

  Enough staffb

300

1.87

(0.70)

285

2.77

(0.70)

300

2.53

(0.57)

300

2.98

(0.25)

  Took best careb

300

1.81

(0.62)

285

2.86

(0.46)

300

2.59

(0.50)

300

2.99

(0.11)

  Trustb

300

2.14

(0.81)

285

2.94

(0.32)

300

2.82

(0.42)

300

2.97

(0.16)

  Clean bathroom

300

1.68

(0.62)

285

1.06

(1.29)

300

2.17

(0.51)

300

2.61

(0.51)

  Safeb

300

2.26

(0.81)

285

2.93

(0.31)

300

2.89

(0.31)

300

2.99

(0.10)

Change Package

  Introduction

300

0.09

(0.30)

285

0.36

(0.97)

300

1.97

(1.13)

300

2.61

(0.74)

  Privacy

300

1.64

(1.01)

285

2.44

(1.17)

300

2.71

(0.63)

300

2.99

(0.17)

  Position of choice

300

1.22

(1.11)

285

2.81

(0.63)

300

2.92

(0.34)

300

2.85

(0.48)

  Clean bathroom

300

1.68

(0.62)

285

1.06

(1.29)

300

2.59

(0.76)

300

2.83

(0.57)

  Explain test and medicine purpose

300

0.89

(0.97)

285

2.21

(1.19)

300

2.38

(0.92)

300

2.85

(0.51)

  Pain medicines given when needed

300

1.27

(0.83)

285

2.45

(1.03)

300

2.29

(0.84)

300

2.99

(0.13)

  Helped to the toilet

300

1.31

(1.25)

285

2.68

(0.76)

300

2.41

(1.07)

300

2.88

(0.48)

  Clean post-natal care ward

300

2.15

(0.86)

285

2.64

(0.76)

300

2.74

(0.48)

300

2.89

(0.33)

  1. aTotal, change package, non-change package and subdomain scores were scaled to a 100-point scale
  2. bDenotes Non-change package indicator