Table 2 Overall domain assessment of CPGs
Clinical Practice Guideline | Scope and Purpose | Stakeholder Involvement | Rigour of Development | Clarity of Presentation | Applicability | Editorial Independence | OVERALL | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
first global rating (Personal rating) | second global rating (I would recommend?) | ||||||||
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) [51] | 2016 | 98,61% | 95,83% | 90,10% | 100,00% | 65,63% | 93,75% | 95,83% | Yes |
Canadian Chiropractic Guideline Initiative (CCGI) [41] | 2018 | 90,28% | 84,72% | 88,54% | 90,28% | 73,96% | 85,42% | 87,50% | Yes |
Belgian Health Care Knowledge Centre (KCE) [47] | 2017 | 88,89% | 77,78% | 83,85% | 69,44% | 86,46% | 95,83% | 83,33% | Yes |
American College of Physicians (ACP) [35] | 2017 | 97,22% | 75,00% | 76,56% | 80,56% | 22,92% | 93,75% | 75,00% | Yes |
Veterans Affairs/Department of Defense (VADoD) Collaboration Office [55] | 2017 | 84,72% | 90,28% | 80,21% | 87,50% | 41,67% | 60,42% | 70,83% | Yes, with mod. |
Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement (ICSI) [46] | 2018 | 80,56% | 72,22% | 68,23% | 86,11% | 51,04% | 79,17% | 62,50% | Yes, with mod. |
Toward Optimized Practice (TOP) Low Back Pain Working Group [54] | 2017 | 69,44% | 48,61% | 66,15% | 77,78% | 71,88% | 75,00% | 58,33% | No |
Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine (KIOM) [48] | 2017 | 72,22% | 40,28% | 47,92% | 59,72% | 1,04% | 83,33% | 45,83% | No |
China Association of Acupuncture-Moxibustion (CAAM) [40] | 2016 | 63,89% | 44,44% | 35,94% | 63,89% | 0,00% | 29,17% | 45,83% | No |
Global Spine Care Initiative (GSCI) [45] | 2018 | 52,78% | 11,11% | 25,00% | 70,83% | 11,46% | 75,00% | 41,67% | No |
American Society of Interventional Pain Physicians (ASIPP) [38] | 2019 | 66,67% | 25,00% | 57,29% | 33,33% | 6,25% | 81,25% | 41,67% | No |
American Osteopathic Association (AOA) [37] | 2016 | 76,39% | 36,11% | 52,60% | 25,00% | 33,33% | 58,33% | 41,67% | No |
Change Pain Latin America (CPLA) [43] | 2018 | 26,39% | 13,89% | 27,60% | 27,78% | 23,96% | 93,75% | 33,33% | No |
Council on Chiropractic Guidelines and Practice Parameters (CCGPP) [42] | 2016 | 43,06% | 33,33% | 53,13% | 47,22% | 16,67% | 66,67% | 29,17% | No |
Dutch Society of Anesthesiologists (DSA) [44] | 2016 | 63,89% | 56,94% | 50,52% | 50,00% | 4,17% | 45,83% | 29,17% | No |
Brazilian Medical Association (BMA) [39] | 2018 | 22,22% | 0,00% | 34,90% | 29,17% | 0,00% | 29,17% | 20,83% | No |
Korean Society of Spine Surgery (KSSS) [49] | 2017 | 15,28% | 2,78% | 17,71% | 20,83% | 0,00% | 29,17% | 8,33% | No |
Polish Spine Surgery Society (PSSS) [53] | 2016 | 20,83% | 2,78% | 12,50% | 29,17% | 0,00% | 62,50% | 8,33% | No |
American Imaging Management (AIM) Specialty Health [36] | 2019 | 18,06% | 8,33% | 6,77% | 27,78% | 0,00% | 0,00% | 4,17% | No |
Polish Society of Physiotherapy (PSP) [52] | 2017 | 22,22% | 0,00% | 1,56% | 19,44% | 0,00% | 33,33% | 4,17% | No |
Labor & Industries (L&I), Washington State [50] | 2016 | 12,50% | 13,89% | 0,00% | 29,17% | 0,00% | 0,00% | 0,00% | No |