Table 3 Characteristics of the 3 articles equating patient-relevant outcomes with self-reported outcomes
From: Patient-relevant outcomes: what are we talking about? A scoping review to improve conceptual clarity
Authors | Objective/ motivation of article | Type of article/ study | Terms used synonymously | Indicator disease/ intervention | Outcomes considered patient-relevant [instrument, if applicable] |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nilsdotter et al. 2009 [37] | 1. Description of outcomes up to five years after total knee replacement for osteoarthritis from the patients’ perspective 2. Evaluation to what extent patients performed physical activities after total knee replacement 3. Identification of preoperative characteristics predicting postoperative outcomes | Prospective follow-up study | 2 terms: - patient-relevant outcome - self-reported outcome | Total knee replacement in osteoarthritis | - general health status [SF-36] - knee-specific health status: pain, stiffness, physical function [WOMAC] - general comorbidity |
Nilsdotter, Isaksson 2010 [38] | Prospective evaluation of patient-relevant outcomes seven years after total hip replacement for osteoarthritis focusing on pain and physical function | Prospective cohort study with matched controls without hip complaints | 2 terms: - patient-relevant outcome - patient-reported outcome | Hybrid total hip replacement and demented total hip replacement for osteoarthritis | - general health status [SF-36] - knee-specific health status: pain, stiffness, physical function [WOMAC] - postoperative complications - general comorbidity - musculoskeletal comorbidity: need of walking assistance, walking distance, pain, need for analgesics, joint replacement in contralateral hip or in knee, fractures - patient satisfaction |
Nilsdotter, Lohmander 2003 [39] | Investigation of pre- and postoperative patient-relevant outcomes between hybrid total hip replacement and cemented total hip replacement in patients with osteoarthritis | Prospective cohort study | 2 terms: - patient-relevant outcome - patient-relevant measure | Total hip replacement for osteoarthritis | - general health status [SF-36] - knee-specific health status: pain, stiffness, physical function [WOMAC] - postoperative complications - general comorbidity - musculoskeletal comorbidity: need of walking assistance, walking distance, pain, need for analgesics, joint replacement in contralateral hip or in knee, fractures |