Skip to main content

Table 1 Description of cancer projects for assessing costs of genomic sequencing

From: Estimating the costs of genomic sequencing in cancer control

 

Lung/Melanoma cancer

Breast cancer

Melanoma

Lung cancer

Oesophageal cancer

Mesothelioma

Description

 Project goal

Direct clinical application: treatment pathway

Direct clinical application: treatment pathway

Risk stratification, surveillance decisions

Determine personalised treatment paths

Determine tumour specific mutations

Determine tumour specific mutations

 Setting

Statewide health service

Statewide health service

Clinical research

Clinical research

Research

Research

 Type of sequencing

Panel

Panel

Exome

Exome

Genome

Genome

 Number of patients

745

192

383

10

100

3

 Commercial services

No, in-house

No, in-house

Yes, freight/sequencing

No, in-house

Yes, freight/sequencing

Yes, freight/sequencing

 Location of sequencing testing

Pathology Queensland, Brisbane

Pathology Queensland, Brisbane

Australian Genomic Research Facility, Melbourne

Australian Translational Genomics Centre, Brisbane

Kinghorn Centre Clinical Genomics, Melbourne

Beijing Genomics Institute, Hong Kong

 Setting/Location of bioinformatics

State government health service, Brisbane

State government health service, Brisbane

University, Brisbane

University, Brisbane

Medical Research Institute, Brisbane

Medical Research Institute, Brisbane

Steps

 1.Sampling

Biopsy sample (no blood)

Blood sample (no tumour)

Saliva - Oragene DNA self-collection kit

Biopsy sample & blood draw

Tumour biopsy & blood draw

Tumour biopsy & blood draw

 2.DNA extraction

DNA Investigator extraction kit,

Qubit dsDNA Broad Range Assay kit

QiaSymphony kit,

Qubit dsDNA Broad Range Assay kit

QiaQuick Gel Extraction Kit, Qubit dsDNA Broad Range Assay kit, Sangar seq validation, BigDye sequencing kit

QiaSymphony kit, DNA midi kits (blood and tumour)

Qiagen AllPrep DNA mini kit,

QiaAMP DNA blood mini kit, Qubit dsDNA Broad Range Assay kit

Qiagen AllPrep DNA/RNA/ miRNA Universal kit, Qubit, SNP arrays

 3.Library preparation

Standardised in-house protocol

Standardised in-house protocol

AGRF - Illumina protocols, automated electrophoresis & qPCR

Pre-sequencing qPCR

GenomeOne – Illumina protocols

MGIEasyâ„¢ DNA Library Prep Kit V1, DNA nanoballs on BGISEQ-500

 4.Sequencing

Illumina MiSeqâ„¢/ NextSeqâ„¢

TruSeq 26-gene panel

Illumina MiSeqâ„¢/ NextSeqâ„¢,In-house panel, MLPA

Illumina NovaSeqâ„¢

Illumina NextSeqâ„¢

Illumina HiSeq XTenâ„¢

BGISEQ-500â„¢

Coverage depth

1000X

500X

>100X

100-130X exome, 500-700X spiked-in gene panel

30X blood, 60X tumour

28X blood, 50X tumour

 5. Analysis

In-house

In-house

In-house

Demultiplexed CASAVA

In-house

In-house

Software for read mapping, variant calling/ annotation

VariantStudio

VariantStudio

Next Gene Soft Genetics

BWA alignment, Picard, GATK Haplotype Caller.

ANNOVAR

Novalign, GATK Haplotype Caller, VEP

SNPs, Dual caller qSNP and GATK Haplotype caller. Indels:Haplotype Caller, Structural rearrangements: qSV

Copy Number: ascatNGS

SNPs, Dual caller qSNP and GATK Haplotype caller. Indels:Haplotype Caller, Structural rearrangements: qSV

Copy Number: ascatNGS

 6. Reporting to clinicians

Standard report – paper and electronic, multidiscip team meeting 10% cases

Standard report – paper and electronic, multidisciplinary team meeting 10% cases

n/a pre-clinical work

Prep time for multidisciplinary team

n/a pre-clinical work

n/a pre-clinical work

 7. Storage needs, 5 yrs

107 TB (2 GB/sample)

28 TB (2 GB/sample)

275 TB (10 GB/sample)

29 TB (20 GB/sample)

529 TB (150 GB/tumour, 72 GB/blood)

26 TB (150 GB/tumour, 72 GB/blood)

  1. Abbreviations: DNA deoxyribose nucleic acid, GAKT Genome Analysis Toolkit, MLPA Multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification, qPCR quantitative polymerase chain reaction, BWA Burrow-Wheeler Aligner, VEP Variant Effect Predictor