Table 4 Summary of the included studies
No | References | Date | Country | Type | Aim | Context | Outcome | QAT summary score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Bando | 2017 | Japan | Literature review | To review precision medicine in Japan and Europe | Oncology and precision medicine | Barriers faced in rapid implementation of precision medicine are apparent in Japan, and further effort and collaboration will be needed for Japan to take a lead in establishing precision medicine | 50 |
2 | Basu | 2013 | America | Quantitative | To provide a more efficient and powerful tool to perform gene-based genome-wide association study with single or multivariate traits | Bio statistics and precision medicine | The authors propose a new approach for rapid implementation for gene-based genome-wide association studies | 100 |
3 | Battaglia | 2018 | America | Literature Review | To discuss pragmatic models, methods, and measures in implementation | Nursing research and enhancing population health | Pragmatic dissemination and implementation approaches are needed to speed up research translation | 50 |
4 | Beck | 2009 | America | Mixed-method | The use of a conceptual framework for implementation and dissemination | Child Care and paediatric practice at a Health Maintenance Organization | Rapid implementation is seen through combining implementation frameworks (PRISM & RE-AIM) and augmenting components with social network analysis | Qual: 90 Quant: 100 |
5 | Bernstein | 2009 | America | Quantitative | To increase the use of smokers’ quitline referral services | Smoking referral Quitline | Marked and sustained use of quitline referral services by health care providers | 100 |
6 | Birenda | 2015 | America | Quantitative | To provide further data to delineate the progression free survival of patients who get treated with targeted therapy in molecular profiling | Cancer | Demonstrates the potential value of molecular profiling. Continued work on rapid implementation of molecular profiling earlier in the care of oncology patients continue to be a future goal | 100 |
7 | Burkard | 2017 | America | Observational | Introducing a state-wide molecular tumor board | Community oncology practices | The molecular tumor board approach provides flexibility and rapid implementation by integrating clinical service, a registry, and a journal club | 40 |
8 | Churruca | 2019 | Australia | Multi-case analysis | Researchers and implementers working together in situ throughout an implementation project | Adapting Implementation Approaches | Embedded implementation research approaches hold promise for rapid implementation | 50 |
9 | Denomme | 2008 | Germany | Commentary | Dry matching to improve transfusion outcomes for widespread implementation by rapid timelines through standards of practice | Blood banks | Discusses rapid implementation of donor-recipient blood group genotype dry-matching would have on reducing the incidence of delayed transfusion reactions and its associated comorbidities | 50 |
10 | Francescatto | 2015 | America | Literature review | Precision medicine and speedy implementation in the clinical setting | New born screening | Discusses rapid implementation through to the possibility of having complete access to our genetic data from birth, if not shortly after conception | 40 |
11 | Gale | 2019 | America | Qualitative | Comparison of rapid transcription procedures | Opioid prescribing in the Veterans Health Administration | Rapid analyses is on the rise providing valid findings in a short timeframe, enabling identification of actionable recommendations | 100 |
12 | Glasgow [1] | 2014 | America | Literature Review | To provide lessons learned from the My Own Health Report Project | Primary care | Conducting complex studies rapidly and efficiently is a realistic goal | 50 |
13 | Glasgow [2] | 2003 | America | Literature Review | To discuss the efficacy-effectiveness trials | Rapid implementation within healthcare | Recommend key conceptual and methodological characteristics are offered to help close the gap | 50 |
14 | Glasgow [3] | 2012 | America | Literature Review | To determine what is needed for rapidly integrating science into practice | Rapid implementation within Health care | Different approaches are needed for rapid robust sustainable real world healthcare programs and policies. To produce different outcomes, we need to think and act differently | 50 |
15 | Glasgow [4] | 2012 | America | Literature Review | To address the gap between current knowledge and practice in the area of dissemination and implementation research | Rapid implementation within healthcare | Further advances in the field will be achieved by focusing dissemination and implementation to become more rapid | 50 |
16 | Guthrie | 2014 | UK | Case Study | Investigating time lags from research to practice | Public charitable investment in cancer research | Having networks in place can support rapid research translation | 50 |
17 | Keith | 2017 | America | Qualitative | Intervention-specific codes, and CFIR constructs to reduce and organize the data to speed up procedures and analysis | Primary care practices | Using the CFIR to guide data collection, coding, analysis, and reporting of findings supported a systematic, comprehensive, and timely understanding of barriers and facilitators to practice transformation | 100 |
18 | Kilbourne | 2017 | America | Literature Review | Using QUERI to support rapid implementation into clinical practice | Rapid implementation within healthcare | Shows how to rapidly translate research findings or evidence-based treatments (best practices) into clinical practice | 100 |
19 | Krier | 2016 | America | Literature Review | To discuss precision medicine applications, challenges and opportunities | Genomic sequencing in clinical practice | Discusses clinical innovation, rapid implementation and complicated implementation questions | 50 |
20 | Peek | 2014 | America | Literature Review | To discuss different approaches to make health care research more relevant and rapid | Rapid implementation within healthcare | Emerging standard of research 5 R’s | 50 |
21 | Rapport [1] | 2018 | Australia | Literature Review | Predicting a new approach to methods | Rapid implementation within healthcare | For rapid implementation we need new methods | 50 |
22 | Rapport [2] | 2018 | Australia | Literature Review | The authors aim to reveal how implementation science is presented and understood in health services to progress our knowledge | Rapid implementation within healthcare | Rapid implementation is about adaption. Implementation science models, theories, and frameworks are critiqued. | 50 |
23 | Reeves | 2013 | America | Literature Review | Exploring ethnography | Rapid ethnography as a method to study healthcare | Rapid ethnography reduces the time spent in observation when compared to traditional ethnography | 60 |
24 | Riley | 2013 | America | Literature Review | Speed up research into practice | Rapid implementation within healthcare | Proposing rapid learning systems to evaluate new and existing treatments | 50 |