Skip to main content

Table 3 Departmental and segmental distribution of evaluation scale of inter-organizational collaboration on NCD management in China, 2014 [n = 444, n(%)]

From: An analysis on intersectional collaboration on non-communicable chronic disease prevention and control in China: a cross-sectional survey on main officials of community health service institutions

Management procedures

Related institutions

Shared goals and vision

Internalization

Governance

Formalization

Total score of the collaboration scale

\( \overline{x} \)

s

\( \overline{x} \)

s

\( \overline{x} \)

s

\( \overline{x} \)

s

\( \overline{x} \)

s

Physical examination1

GH

5.48

0.79

5.54

0.69

10.08

2.01

5.17

1.16

26.26

3.59

CDC

5.54

0.76

5.45

0.77

9.90

2.04

5.20

1.07

26.09

3.51

CMI

5.56

0.75

5.42

0.78

9.84

2.18

5.10

1.24

25.91

3.89

PA

5.61

0.71

5.52

0.74

10.42

1.99

5.58

0.95

27.13

3.17

Others

5.64

0.68

5.54

0.79

10.21

2.20

5.50

0.96

26.89

3.52

F

0.67

 

0.93

 

1.57

 

3.54

 

2.23

 

p value

0.61

 

0.45

 

0.18

 

0.01

 

0.06

 

Health record establishment2

GH

5.49

0.72

5.48

0.70

10.13

1.88

5.28

0.99

26.39

3.20

CDC

5.54

0.81

5.32

0.81

9.46

2.20

5.02

1.11

25.32

3.89

CMI

5.53

0.78

5.46

0.74

9.98

2.10

5.17

1.20

26.14

3.75

PA

5.72

0.63

5.49

0.77

10.70

1.82

5.72

0.59

27.63

2.65

Others

5.50

0.71

5.61

0.78

10.39

2.25

5.72

0.57

27.22

3.32

F

0.80

 

1.24

 

3.23

 

4.74

 

3.88

 

p value

0.52

 

0.29

 

0.01

 

0.00

 

0.00

 

Exercise and nutrition intervention3

GH

5.46

0.79

5.52

0.72

10.07

1.89

5.22

1.05

26.27

3.40

CDC

5.57

0.74

5.40

0.80

9.75

2.12

5.11

1.14

25.82

3.79

CMI

5.54

0.75

5.47

0.74

9.96

2.20

5.12

1.25

26.10

3.83

PA

5.52

0.75

5.49

0.80

10.46

1.93

5.51

0.95

26.98

3.33

Others

5.50

0.79

5.61

0.78

10.06

2.21

5.61

0.85

26.78

3.39

F

0.47

 

0.83

 

2.17

 

3.31

 

1.99

 

p value

0.76

 

0.50

 

0.07

 

0.01

 

0.09

 

Psychological consultation

GH

5.51

0.75

5.59

0.67

10.28

1.84

5.28

1.03

26.66

3.22

CDC

5.48

0.82

5.45

0.77

10.04

1.99

5.21

1.10

26.18

3.54

CMI

5.49

0.81

5.51

0.74

10.14

2.13

5.26

1.15

26.40

3.81

PA

5.49

0.79

5.58

0.79

10.63

1.84

5.63

0.84

27.34

3.11

Others

5.41

0.80

5.59

0.85

9.91

2.43

5.45

1.06

26.36

3.92

F

0.10

 

0.70

 

1.16

 

1.95

 

1.28

 

p value

0.98

 

0.59

 

0.33

 

0.10

 

0.28

 

Medication guidance4

GH

5.49

0.77

5.52

0.71

10.06

1.96

5.18

1.16

26.24

3.51

CDC

5.54

0.79

5.45

0.79

10.02

2.12

5.23

1.12

26.24

3.69

CMI

5.51

0.80

5.51

0.75

10.15

2.06

5.26

1.11

26.43

3.58

PA

5.58

0.76

5.58

0.79

10.58

1.89

5.67

0.88

27.42

3.11

Others

5.44

0.81

5.50

0.89

9.94

2.29

5.56

0.89

26.44

3.67

F

0.21

 

0.31

 

0.84

 

2.43

 

1.26

 

p value

0.93

 

0.87

 

0.50

 

0.04

 

0.29

 

Medical referral servic(medical green channel)

GH

5.47

0.80

5.52

0.72

10.16

1.91

5.17

1.18

26.32

3.45

CDC

5.53

0.80

5.47

0.75

10.25

2.02

5.25

1.06

26.51

3.53

CMI

5.58

0.73

5.45

0.73

10.31

2.02

5.19

1.16

26.54

3.62

PA

5.69

0.69

5.53

0.76

10.91

1.80

5.69

0.74

27.81

2.83

Others

5.67

0.65

5.25

0.97

9.75

2.80

5.33

1.23

26.00

4.63

F

0.89

 

0.49

 

1.21

 

1.52

 

1.34

 

p value

0.47

 

0.74

 

0.30

 

0.20

 

0.25

 

Rehabilitation guidance

GH

5.40

0.81

5.50

0.73

10.29

1.99

5.19

1.20

26.39

3.66

CDC

5.47

0.82

5.47

0.73

10.28

1.88

5.28

0.97

26.50

3.29

CMI

5.54

0.76

5.51

0.68

10.16

2.00

5.09

1.25

26.31

3.63

PA

5.65

0.66

5.61

0.70

10.75

1.92

5.49

1.03

27.49

3.16

Others

5.50

0.73

5.44

0.89

10.06

2.57

5.38

0.81

26.38

3.96

F

1.15

 

0.34

 

0.89

 

1.34

 

1.16

 

p value

0.33

 

0.85

 

0.47

 

0.25

 

0.33

 
  1. Note: General hospitals (GH),CDC, Community management institutions(CMI),Propaganda authorities(PA),Others. Analysis of variance and post-hoc comparison revealed that, 1: Difference existed between PA and GH, CDC, CMI; 2: In relation to governance dimension, difference existed between CDC and GH, CMI, PA; it was also seen between CMI and PA. On the formalization dimension, difference existed between PA and GH, CDC, CMI; it was also seen between other institutions and CDC, CMI. With respect to the total score of the collaboration scale, difference existed between CDC and GH, CMI; it was also seen between PA and CMI, others. 3: Statistical difference existed between PA and GH, CDC, CMI. 4: Statistical difference existed between PA and GH, CDC, CMI