Skip to main content

Table 4 Incidence risk ratio (IRR) and 95 % confidence interval (CI) of outpatient care utilization with four types of status of public and private health insurance in the Korea Health Panel Survey, 2008–2011

From: Effects of public and private health insurance on medical service utilization in the National Health Insurance System: National panel study in the Republic of Korea

 

Model I

Model II

Model III

Model IV

IRR

95 % CI

IRR

95 % CI

IRR

95 % CI

IRR

95 % CI

Gender (Ref.: Men)

1

 

1

 

1

 

1

 

 Women

1.58***

1.53–1.63

1.52***

1.47–1.57

1.52***

1.47–1.57

1.52***

1.48–1.57

Age (Ref.: 20–29)

1

 

1

 

1

 

1

 

 30–39

1.09***

1.05–1.13

1.05**

1.01–1.09

1.04*

1.01–1.09

1.05*

1.01–1.09

 40–49

1.29***

1.24–1.35

1.20***

1.15–1.25

1.19***

1.14–1.24

1.19***

1.14–1.24

 50–59

1.73***

1.65–1.81

1.52***

1.45–1.59

1.51***

1.44–1.58

1.51***

1.44–1.58

 60 or older

2.40***

2.29–2.51

2.04***

1.94–2.14

2.03***

1.93–2.13

2.03***

1.93–2.13

Chronic disease (Ref.: No)

1

 

1

 

1

 

1

 

 Yes

1.98***

1.96–2.01

1.97***

1.94–2.00

1.97***

1.94–1.99

1.97***

1.94–1.99

Marital status (Ref.: Single)

1

 

1

 

1

 

1

 

 Married couple

1.73***

1.66–1.81

1.67***

1.60–1.75

1.69***

1.61–1.79

1.69***

1.61–1.76

 Divorced or Separated

1.95***

1.84–2.07

1.86***

1.75–1.98

1.85***

1.74–1.97

1.85***

1.74–1.97

 Separation by death

1.92***

1.82–2.02

1.76***

1.70–1.89

1.79***

1.70–1.89

1.79***

1.70–1.89

Education (Ref.: College Degree or higher)

  

1

 

1

 

1

 

 High School to associate

  

1.16***

1.12–1.21

1.15***

1.11–1.19

1.15***

1.11–1.19

 Middle School to associate

  

1.34***

1.28–1.41

1.33***

1.27–1.39

1.33***

1.27–1.39

 Elementary School or less

  

1.55***

1.48–1.63

1.53***

1.46–1.60

1.53***

1.46–1.60

Household income (Ref.: 1st quartile, lowest)

  

1

 

1

 

1

1

 2st quartile

  

0.98**

0.97–0.99

0.98**

0.97–0.99

0.98**

0.97–0.99

 3st quartile

  

0.99**

0.97–0.99

0.99

0.98–1.00

0.99

0.98–1.00

 4st quartile (highest)

  

0.99

0.98–1.00

0.99

0.98–1.00

0.99

0.98–1.00

Healthcare covered by NHI (Ref.: Yes)

    

1

   

 No (medical aid)

    

1.23***

1.20–1.26

  

Purchase of PHI (Ref.: No)

    

1

   

 Yes

    

1.02

0.99–1.03

  

NHI status x PHI status (Ref.: Covered by only NHI)

      

1

 

 Covered by only the medical aid

      

1.23***

1.19–1.26

 Covered by both NHI and PHI

      

1.01

0.99–1.03

 Covered by both the medical aid and PHI

      

1.25***

1.21–1.29

  1. Note NHI National Health Insurance, PHI Private Health Insurance, Dependent variable: used outpatient care during the last year (1); not used outpatient care during the last year (0)
  2. All models are additionally adjusted for age, gender, marital status, and chronic diseases
  3. *p < 0.05
  4. **p < 0.01
  5. ***p < 0.001