Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of the characteristics of respondents and non-respondents

From: An evaluation of the appropriateness of advice and healthcare contacts made following calls to NHS Direct Wales

  

Survey 1

 

Survey 2

 
  

Respondents

Non-Respondents

p

Respondents

Non-Respondents

p

NHSDW Call Type

       

Direct calls:

Triage

572 (60.4)

580 (61.2)

0.37

311 (54.7)

372 (58.6)

0.16

 

General information

267 (28.2)

248 (26.2)

 

216 (38.0)

206 (32.4)

 

Indirect calls:

GP out of hours

103 (10.9)

114 (12.0)

 

25 (4.4)

26 (4.1)

 
 

A&E/Ambulance

5 (0.5)

5 (0.5)

 

3 (0.5)

8 (1.3)

 
 

Dental helpline

0 (0.0)

0 (0.0)

 

14 (2.4)

23 (3.6)

 
 

Missing/Misdirected

3

0 (0.0)

 

0 (0.0)

0 (0.0)

 
 

Total

950* (100.0)

947 (100.0)

 

569 (100.0)

635 (100.0)

 

NHSDW Dispositions

       
 

999/A&E

75 (7.9)

91 (9.6)

0.54

54 (9.5)

58 (9.1)

0.68

 

Emergency GP

237 (24.9)

231 (24.4)

 

91 (16.0)

96 (15.1)

 
 

GP

208 (21.9)

177 (18.7)

 

94 (16.5)

107 (16.9)

 
 

Dentist

15 (1.6)

20 (2.1)

 

28 (4.9)

51 (8.0)

 
 

Other

13 (1.4)

31 (3.3)

 

16 (2.8)

22 (3.5)

 
 

Pharmacist

7 (0.7)

3 (0.3)

 

6 (1.1)

6 (0.9)

 
 

Dentist information

0 (0.0)

0 (0.0)

 

117 (20.6)

128 (20.2)

 
 

Home care/Information

355 (37.4)

356 (37.6)

 

141 (24.8)

144 (22.7)

 
 

Unclassifiable

40 (4.2)

38 (4.0)

 

22 (3.9)

23 (3.6)

 
 

Total

950 (100.0)

947 (100.0)

 

569 (100.0)

635 (100.0)

 

Gender

       
 

Male

262 (27.6)

295 (31.2)

0.08

192 (33.7)

216 (34.1)

0.95

 

Female

688 (72.4)

650 (68.8)

 

377 (66.3)

418 (65.9)

 
 

Missing

0 (0.0)

2

 

0 (0.0)

1

 
 

Total

950 (100.0)

947 (100.0)

 

569 (100.0)

635 (100.0)

 

*7 returned questionnaires were missing a call id and as a result, although they were useable questionnaires bringing the total number up to 957, they have been included here as non respondents as they could not be identified to remove.

   
  1. *7 returned questionnaires were missing a call id and as a result, although they were useable questionnaires bringing the total number up to 957, they have been included here as non respondents as they could not be identified to remove.