Skip to main content

Table 3 Marginal WTP estimates (£/month)

From: Prioritising health service innovation investments using public preferences: a discrete choice experiment

 

MNL

Class-1 (54%)

Class-2 (34%)

Class-3 (12%)

Weighted average

Target people:

9.31 (1.84 – 16.79)

4.28 (−6.53 – 15.09)

4.31 (−5.22 – 13.85)

30.41 (10.86 – 49.96)

7.46 (0.61 – 14.31)

People with disability

People with drug addiction

−61.01 (−69.38 – -52.64)

−80.38 (−96.12 – -64.64)

−10.25 (−21.97 – 1.46)

−31.86 (−76.58 – 12.87)

−50.82 (−60.60 – -41.03)

People with cancer

40.77 (32.06 – 49.48)

37.00 (18.49 – 55.51)

19.77 (8.20 – 31.34)

64.29 (38.51 – 90.07)

34.49 (23.72 – 45.26)

People with mental health problems

Baseline level

People with obesity

−47.28 (−55.43 – -39.13)

−62.43 (−73.46 – -51.40)

−10.49 (−20.92 – -0.07)

19.76 (−1.90 – 41.42)

−34.93 (−42.00 – -27.85)

People with asthma

−1.51 (−9.83 – 6.81)

−10.74 (−20.04 – -1.44)

8.32 (−3.49 – 20.13)

20.42 (0.58 – 40.26)

−0.53 (−7.19 – 6.14)

Target age:

     

Young (less than 18)

11.61 (7.16 – 16.06)

17.22 (11.24 – 23.20)

3.92 (−0.61 – 8.45)

−28.11 (−46.48 – -9.74)

7.23 (3.27 – 11.19)

Adults (18–65)

14.41 (9.82 – 18.99)

19.94 (12.82 – 27.07)

4.90 (−0.10 – 9.89)

−21.30 (−34.94 – -7.65)

9.86 (5.57 – 14.15)

Elderly (more than 65)

Baseline level

Implementation time:

Between 6–12 months

−2.69 (−6.81 – 1.44)

0.48 (−3.71 – 4.68)

−3.76 (−7.92 – 0.40)

2.05 (−8.67 – 12.77)

−0.76 (−3.61 – 2.09)

More than 12 months

−2.76 (−6.88 – 1.37)

−1.24 (−5.43 – 2.96)

−1.28 (−5.10 – 2.55)

−9.51 (−23.37 – 4.36)

−2.25 (−5.18 – 0.67)

Between 0–5 months

Baseline level

Whether it works:

It works but not scientifically proven

−14.66 (−18.88 – -10.44)

−10.41 (−15.52 – -5.30)

−8.49 (−13.18 – -3.80)

−19.68 (−33.83 – -5.53)

−10.89 (−14.63 – -7.14)

Experts say it works elsewhere in the NHS

−1.65 (−16.82 – 13.51)

−4.14 (−8.20 – -0.09)

−0.91 (−4.77 – 2.96)

−4.79 (−15.39 – 5.81)

−3.13 (−5.85 – -0.41)

It works and scientific studies confirm this

Baseline level

Potential health benefits:

Moderate health (50%)

Baseline level

Good health (75%)

15.45 (11.09 – 19.82)

9.51 (5.02 – 14.01)

9.20 (4.83 – 13.56)

−0.71 (−12.31 – 10.89)

8.17 (5.10 – 11.24)

Best health (100%)

20.11 (15.61 – 24.61)

13.94 (7.79 – 20.09)

12.44 (7.08 – 17.80)

−0.53 (−12.90 – 11.84)

11.68 (7.87 – 15.49)

  1. Figures in parentheses are confidence intervals at the 95% level, obtained using the delta method. Baseline levels are chosen arbitrarily.