Healthcare system intervention for prevention of birth injuries – process evaluation of self-assessment, peer review, feedback and agreement for change

Table 5 The anticipated and deviant patterns of maternity units expressed in percentage of text segments

	A) Self assessment (%)			B Peer review (%)			C Written feedback, signing contract, planning action (%)
	Ideal	Neutral	Negative	Ideal	Neutral	Negative	Ideal	Neutral	Negative
Maternity units - Sequence I (n = 14)
I-1	63	34	3	9	78	13	0	12	88
I-2	58	42	0	9	77	14	30	60	10
I-3	62	38	0	19	70	11	42	58	0
I-4	48,5	48,5	3	10	90	0	43	43	14
I-5	58	42	0	43	57	0	50	45	5
I-6	58	42	0	20	67	13	0	43	57
I-7	60	36	4	0	59	41	13	56	31
I-8	50	50	0	24	70	6	50	50	0
I-9	75	25	0	25	55	20	41	47	12
I-10	47	43	10	25	69	6	46	36	18
I-11	50	19	31	26	48	26	54	31	15
I-12	48	35	17	8	25	67	38	29	33
I-13	86	9	5	15	85	0	36	50	14
I-14	53	47	0	10,5	79	10,5	33	56	11
Range	47-86	9-50	0-31	0-43	25-90	0-67	0-54	12-60	0-88
Mean	58,3	36,5	5,2	17,4	66,4	16,25	34	44	22
SD	11,0	11,7	8,9	10,9	16,8	18,4	17,6	13,3	24,2
Maternity units - Sequence II (n = 13)
II-15	70,5	22	7,5	13,5	73	13,5	69	15,5	15,5
II-16	61	26	13	0	100	0	44	56	0
II-17	67	29	4	29	62	9	50	29	21
II-18	72	9	19	14	86	0	71,5	21,5	7
II-19	59	38	3	25	67	8	33	40	27
II-20	70	27	3	20	67	13	36,5	27	36,5
II-21	62	32	6	0	82	18	61	22	17
II-22	58	39	3	40	60	0	74	26	0
II-23	60	40	0	42	58	0	38,5	38,5	23
II-24	75	25	0	7	93	0	58,5	33	8,5
II-25	53	36	11	7	80	13	34,5	34,5	31
II-26	59	26	15	18	64	18	56	22	22
II-27	42	37	21	17	83	0	53	47	0
Range	42-75	9-40	0-21	0-42	58-100	0-18	33-74	15,5-56	0-36,5
Mean	62,2	29,7	8,1	17,9	75	7,1	52,3	31,7	16
SD	8,9	8,7	7,0	13,4	13,4	7,4	14,3	11,4	12,2

ISSN: 1472-6963