Skip to main content

Table 3 Specialist referral and waiting list prioritisation instruments, levels and scores for THA and TKA

From: Determinants of demand for total hip and knee arthroplasty: a systematic literature review

CAHTA*

CPAC**

WCWLP***

Criteria

Level

Score

Criteria

Level

Score

Criteria

Level

Score

Severity of disease (clinical and radiological exploration)

Moderate

0

Pain on examination

None

0

   
 

Severe

18

 

Mild

6

   
    

Moderate

15

   
    

Severe

30

   
   

Other abnormal findings

None

0

Abnormal findings on physical exam

None/mild

0

    

Mild

2

 

Moderate

5

    

Moderate

5

 

Severe

9

    

Severe

10

   
   

Multiple joint involvement

No

0

   
    

Yes, affected joints with moderate severity

4

   
    

Yes, severe involvement

10

   

Pain

Mild

0

Degree of pain

None

0

Pain on motion

None/mild

0

 

Moderate

17

 

Mild

4

 

Moderate

13

 

Severe

33

 

Mild to moderate

6

 

Severe

20

    

Moderate

9

   
    

Moderate to severe

14

   
    

Severe

20

Pain at rest

  

Probability of recovery

Moderate

0

      
 

High

4

      

Difficult in doing ADL

Some difficulty

0

Time walked

Unlimited

0

Ability to walk without significant pain

Over 5 blocks

0

 

Great difficulty

10

 

31-60 min.

2

 

1-5 blocks

4

 

Unable to do most ADL

20

 

11-30 min.

4

 

Less than 1 block

8

    

2-10 min.

6

 

Household ambulatory

13

    

2 < min. or indoors only

8

   
    

Unable to walk

10

   
   

Other functional limitations

None

0

Other functional limitations (ADL)

None

0

    

Mild

2

 

Mild

2

    

Moderate

4

 

Moderate

4

    

Severe

10

 

Severe (unable to do most activities)

10

Limitation on ability to work

No/does not work

0

Ability to work, give care to dependents or live independently

Not threatened or difficult

0

Ability to work, give care to dependents or live independently

Not threatened but more difficult

0

 

Yes

10

      
    

Not threatened but more difficult

4

 

Threatened but not immediately

7

Has someone to look after the patient

Yes

0

      
 

No

9

 

Threatened, but not immediately

6

 

Immediately threatened

10

Be a care-giver

No

0

      
 

Yes

6

 

Immediately threatened

10

   
  1. *Catalan Agency for Health Technology Assessment [62]; **Clinical Priority Assessment Criteria [63].***Western Canada Waiting List Program [65] (asks about situation over the past three months).