Skip to main content

Table 1 Patient and treatment characteristics associated with non-cure in Yunnan province, China (N = 841)

From: Risk factors for non-cure among new sputum smear positive tuberculosis patients treated in tuberculosis dispensaries in Yunnan, China

Characteristic

N(%)

non-cure (%)

RR

95% CI

p-value

Sex

    

0.27

Male

575 (68.4)

37 (6.4)

1

  

Female

266 (31.6)

12 (4.5)

0.69

0.35 - 1.3

 

Age (years)

    

0.66

<30

285 (33.9)

18 (6.3)

1

  

≥30

556 (66.1)

31 (5.6)

0.88

0.48 - 1.6

 

Education level**

    

0.01

No formal education or primary school only

520 (62.6)

38 (7.3)

1

  

Secondary school or higher

311 (37.4)

10 (3.2)

0.42

0.21 - 0.86

 

Medical insurance

    

0.02

No

153 (18.2)

15 (9.8)

1

  

Yes

688 (81.8)

34 (4.9)

0.48

0.32 - 0.90

 

Income*,**

    

0.11

Low

314 (37.3)

21 (6.7)

1

  

Middle

239 (28.4)

18 (7.5)

1.1

0.59 - 2.2

 

High

288 (34.3)

10 (3.5)

0.50

0.23 - 1.12

 

Co-morbidity

    

0.06

No

755 (89.8)

40 (5.3)

1

  

Yes

86 (10.2)

9 (11.6)

2.1

0.98 - 4.5

 

Patient delay (days)

    

0.02

<30

243 (28.9)

7 (2.9)

1

  

≥30

598 (71.1)

42 (7.5)

2.5

1.1 - 5.8

 

Directly observed treatment

    

0.01

Yes, by health care staff

108 (12.8)

4 (3.7)

1

  

Yes, shared by health care staff and family member

85 (10.1)

9 (10.6)

3.1

0.9 - 10.4

 

Yes, by family member

415 (49.3)

15 (1.8)

0.98

0.32 - 3.0

 

No

233 (27.7)

21 (9.0)

2.6

0.86 - 7.7

 

Sputum smear status before treatment

    

0.03

≤2+

503 (59.8)

22 (4.4)

1

  

>2+

338 (40.2)

27 (8.0)

1.9

1.1 - 3.4

 

Sputum smear result after 2 months of treatment

    

0.01

Negative

726 (86.3)

21 (2.9)

1

  

Positive

98 (11.7)

11 (11.1)

4.2

2.0 - 9.1

 

Without test

17 (2.0)

17 (100)

34.8

24.7 - 48.6#

 

Adverse events**

    

0.06

No

539 (65.8)

22 (4.1)

1

  

Yes, did not require hospitalization

262 (32.0)

10 (3.8)

0.93

0.44 - 2.0

 

Yes, required hospitalization

18 (2.2)

3 (16.7)

4.7

1.3 - 17.4

 

Interruption of treatment

    

0.17

No

686 (81.6)

39 (5.7)

1

  

Yes, during intensive phase

28 (3.3)

3 (10.7)

2.0

0.58 - 6.9

 

Yes, during continued phase

96 (11.4)

3 (3.1)

0.54

0.16 - 1.8

 

Yes, during intensive and continuation phase

31 (3.7)

4 (12.9)

2.5

0.82 - 7.4

 

Maximum number of missed doses in a row**

    

0.09

0

682 (81.6)

35 (5.1)

1

  

1-7

102(12.2)

3 (2.9)

0.56

0.17 - 1.9

 

>7

52 (6.2)

6 (11.5)

2.4

0.97 - 6.0

 

Taking drugs according to guideline

    

< 0.001

Yes

638 (75.9)

19 (3.0)

1

  

No

203 (24.1)

30 (14.8)

5.7

3.1 - 10.3

 

Patient knows that during treatment he/she should go to CDC for medical check-ups**

    

< 0.001

Yes

752 (91.0)

22 (2.9)

1

  

No

74 (9.0)

14 (18.9)

7.7

3.8 - 15.9

 

Patient knows the duration of TB treatment

    

0.001

Yes

518 (61.6)

19 (3.7)

1

  

No

323 (38.4)

30 (9.3)

2.7

1.5 - 4.9

 

Patient agrees with the need for treatment observation**

    

0.06

Yes

209 (25.3)

4 (1.9)

1

  

No

616 (74.7)

31 (5.0)

2.7

0.95 - 7.8

 

Family attitude**

    

0.07

More supportive than usual

339 (40.3)

9 (2.7)

1

  

No change or less supportive than usual

502 (59.7)

40 (8.0)

2.1

0.95 - 4.5

 
  1. RR = Relative Risk, 95%CI = 95% confidence interval
  2. * based on tertiles
  3. # As there is one cell with a zero, we cannot estimate RR directly. We added 0.5 to each cell to estimate the RR.
  4. ** numbers do not add up to 841 due to missing values