MAA Category | Commercial Agreement | Payment for Performance Agreement | Coverage with Evidence Development |
---|---|---|---|
Contract type | • Discount-based contract | • Permanent risk-shifting agreement (outcomes guarantee/insurance) applied on a per-patient basis | • Provisional agreement until new, clearly specified evidence develops from a cohort of patients |
Collection and analysis of patient health outcomes data by the payer | • None | • Per patient | • Cohort of patients |
Timeframe of the MAA | • Permanent/not linked to final decision-making | • Permanent/not linked to final decision-making based on new robust evidence | • Temporary/provisional until new evidence allows making a final decision |
Underlying concept (payer perspective) | • Reducing pharmaceutical expenditure | • Avoiding inefficient expenditure on treating patients who do not respond to a drug and who cannot be identified ex ante (by permanently linking the payment to drug's performance in individual patients) | • Reducing uncertainty about drug's real-life effectiveness (by linking a final HTA, reimbursement and/or pricing decision to drug's performance in a cohort of patients, during a defined test period) |
Examples | • Flat price per patient (regardless of the number of doses administered) • Cost Sharing • Rebate • Discount | • Payment for performance • Pay-back for non performance | • Temporary coverage on a condition that new evidence reduces uncertainty about a pre-specified health outcome: - Real-life effectiveness - Higher efficacy in a pre-specified subpopulation of patients - Long-term effect - Improved patient's adherence - Reduction of use of health care resources (e.g. hospitalization) |